The first week of August was a perfect kind of week. The Berkeley City Council was on summer recess and so were most of the boards and commissions. Trump was finally indicted for his attempted coup culminating on January 6 and I managed to fit in Oppenheimer, Barbie and finish Thomas E. Ricks’ Churchill and Orwell.
As you might expect, I’ve read both of Jack Smith’s indictments of Trump and suggest you read them too. I doubt that the MAGA crowd/MAGA cult who according to polls believe that “these are just made up charges” and “Trump won the 2020 election” would change their minds, but it would be a good idea for them too. Nonetheless, there is a reason Trump is sweating, but remember he is a media master.
DC indictment for Jan 6: (45 pages) - https://www.justice.gov/storage/US_v_Trump_23_cr_257.pdf
Florida Documents Case: For those of us who are not lawyers, we do not have to find the June 8 indictment and then the July 27 superseding indictment. The July 27, 2023 superseding indictment contains the original June 8 indictment with the new charges added making it one document (60 pages). - https://www.justice.gov/storage/US-v-Trump-Nauta-De-Oliveira-23-80101.pdf
It is official now: July 2023 was the hottest month recorded, with July 4th as the hottest day. The planet crossed the 1.5°C of temperature rise at least temporarily. I added Phoenix to the cities I track.
While Berkeley basked in afternoons of the gentle 70s, those living in Phoenix got a taste of what 1.5°C of temperature rise feels like, with 31 days of temperatures over 110°F. People who were so unfortunate as to fall on Phoenix streets and sidewalks suffered 2nd and 3rd degree burns.
The heat wave finally broke on July 31, 2023 when the peak temperature dropped to 108°.
Burns from contact with scorching pavement and sidewalks or heat stroke are not the only worries from excessive heat waves. Chronic Kidney Disease of nontraditional or unknown cause CKDnT is being added to the list. CKDnT aka kidney failure has been showing up in medical journals and articles linking CKDnT to outdoor laborers working under extreme heat conditions. This week CKDnT made it into Time in “Chronic Kidney Disease Is Poised to Become the Black Lung of Climate Change.” https://time.com/6303020/chronic-kidney-disease-climate-change/
Andrew Needlam wrote in his August 4 article in the Atlantic “The Problem With ‘Why Do People Live in Phoenix?’” that, “America’s hottest city is still booming…the horror stories of life in 115 degrees is hardly guaranteed to blunt Phoenix’s explosive growth. There are currently building permits for 80,000 new homes in the Phoenix metro area that have not yet commenced construction – homes that will require more water, more AC, and more energy.”
People are still moving to places that will be unlivable part or much of the year in a future that Secretary-General Antonio Guterres described as “[T]he era of global warming has ended; the era of global boiling has arrived…” This is insane.
As I was getting ready for this Diary final clean-up, I joined the monthly zoom meeting with my college classmates. While we were on, the news banner flashed across my screen that the youth who sued that Montana violated their right to a “clean and healthful environment” WON.
After I shared the announcement, I asked my classmate living in Texas how people felt about climate change. Did they think it was real? She said yes, they believed climate change was real and we should get off fossil fuels. She confessed to liking her gas stove and since electricity was created by burning coal, she didn’t feel compelled to get rid of it.
As the discussion continued, she spoke about how young people are depressed, and then followed that with observing that every generation has their challenges: “They just need to put their big boy pants on.”
I was stunned. Is this really how we feel? Children just need to suck it up, put on their big boy pants and deal with the mess we’ve left? I guess this is why I never felt any connection to my college classmates and rarely join the monthly zoom. We have completely different perceptions of the world, then and now.
Lahaina is in the news everywhere. The number of deaths has now eclipsed Paradise, California, making Lahaina the deadliest fire in over 100 years. As people sort through their losses and trauma, they say what we always hear: They will rebuild.
Rebuilding after a disaster may replace destroyed buildings with new, but what happens to community is the subject of Jake Bittle’s book The Great Displacement: Climate Change and the Next American Migration. Bittle takes us into the personal stories of how people’s lives are impacted and changed from the Four Horsemen of the Anthropocene, fire, heat, drought and flood. The book is worth reading. Paradise is in it.
The investigations into the causes and the responses to the fire that engulfed Lahaina has barely started, but already there are similarities to Paradise and the Oakland-Berkeley Hills fires.
There was a small fire earlier in the day that was thought to be out and within several hours it exploded into a conflagration. Evacuation notices were delayed and when sent were on systems that were down/no longer working. There were few evacuation/escape routes. People hesitated to leave, then found themselves trapped by fire and abandoned cars and fled on foot for their lives.
The Maui siren warning system was not activated. The Lahaina fire moved at a mile a minute.
Berkeley’s installation of a siren warning system is nearly complete according to the Deputy Fire Chief Kenneth May.
At the one Berkeley Commission I did attend the first week in August, JaniceThomas from Panoramic Hill said at the Disaster and Fire Safety Commission, she was more afraid of the commission than – I thought she said living on Panoramic Hill, but it could have been the Fire Marshal’s report or something else, I couldn’t be sure. It is so much easier to catch full phrases on zoom especially when live transcription is activated.
There is not much reason to be afraid of commissions after watching what City Council does with commission recommendations. They don’t seem to hold much sway unless the recommendation is something Council is already is favor of doing.
The entire discussion and comments from Thomas started because Commissioner Raine (appointed by District 6 Councilmember Robinson) put the California Office of the State Fire Marshal’s review of the Panoramic Hill neighborhood on the agenda.
The State Fire Marshal report rates Panoramic Hill as very high fire risk and recommends to create a secondary access, install reflective signage, limit street parking, require locked private gates to remain unlocked during red flag warnings or high fire danger conditions, conduct community-wide evacuation drills and install reflective markings to indicate road edges during periods of low visibility (think smoke). Many edges of the roads drop off steeply into canyons.
It seemed like several members of the Disaster and Fire Safety Commission were unfamiliar with the designation of Panoramic Hill as a Fire Zone 3 area, meaning it is at the highest risk in Berkeley of a wildland-urban fire, even though Panoramic Hill managed to escape both the 1923 fire that stopped just short of Shattuck and a block from University and the Berkeley Oakland Hills fire of 1991.
Escape is the key word, the same word that describes why Point Molate should never be a housing development site, one way in and out.
The roads in Panoramic Hill were built in the 1880s according to Thomas.
I was glad I no longer had my Saab with a clutch when I drove them Saturday in my little Prius just to see how bad they really are. When I met a car coming down as I was going up, one of us had to pull over to let the other pass. The passage is too narrow for two cars side by side and definitely too narrow for a wide-bodied fire engine and car to pass side by side.
With all the sharp turns and cars parked on the edges, if a wildfire hits this area it is hard to imagine people getting out or a fire truck coming in, though Commissioner Shirley Dean (Berkeley Mayor from 1994 – 2002) related during the meeting discussion that she once rode in an open cab fire truck up Panoramic Hill to understand the full difficulty of navigating a fire response to the area.
My annoyance with the commissioners, that they didn’t seem to have a full grasp of the City of Berkeley Fire Zones, ended when I went looking for Berkeley’s Fire Zone Map. Finding that map in the new revised city website was definitely a challenge. The map is only a gross picture containing no street names for the borders. https://berkeleyca.gov/sites/default/files/2022-04/Berkeley-Fire-Zone-Map.pdf
At one time,, according to Dean (decades ago), there were plans for a second road route out. Thomas said she still had those records. The item was continued to the next meeting.
Dean’s agenda item to look into development fees for high-rise buildings met with pushback from Commissioner Theo Gordon appointed by District 8 Councilmember Humbert. Gordon said that property owners in the hills should be paying higher fees, not the developers of high-rises, since the new high-rises are more fire resistant and have lower rents. Panoramic Hill is in District 8.
I wasn’t quite sure where Gordon gets his information: claiming that the new mixed-use buildings are cheaper to rent than older existing buildings. Councilmember Harrison has stated at council meetings that our most affordable housing is our existing housing.
When I related Gordon’s comments that new high-rises are cheaper to rent to people who follow the cost of rentals in Berkeley, they called the comment laughable, and asked if Gordon is a paid YIMBY staffer or a true believer. California YIMBY is the land-use lobbying group for Big Tech and developers that celebrates big mixed use projects.
A light search on google and Gordon’s twitter handle lists him as the Lead of East Bay YIMBY. Gordon isn’t listed as staff on the California YIMBY website, but the average annual YIMBY Action Salary for Lead is approximately $175,423 according to Salary.Com. https://www.salary.com/
As for the new high-rise units being cheaper to rent, the 10% very low income units calculated on the “base project” hardly make the other 90%, market rate units, affordable for people who do not have a job earning more than the area median income (AMI) in Alameda County. That is currently at $147,900 for a four person household. Rentals for under $1000 listed in the various online rental apps are by the “bed” not by the unit.
Setting aside 10% of the units for very low income households using the “base project” for calculation is how developers access the California State Density Bonus to increase a project size by 50% more than what would be allowed under existing zoning code. This is how 2190 Shattuck can provide 32 very low income units out of 326 and go from 18 floors to 25 or 1598 University (appeal date 10/3/23) with 21 very low income units out of 207 went from 4 stories to 8.
Dean’s item on a developer’s fee stems from Fire Chief Sprague’s comments at the April 27, 2023 Budget and Finance Committee regarding how many firefighters are needed for a high-rise building, which is any building above 7 floors. Sprague said that the change really comes at above 5 floors. Thirty firefighters would be needed for a residential fire, but 50 – 100 for an elevated fire. Any fire in a high-rise that is more than a couple of rooms would need several 100 firefighters. Sprague’s statement is quoted in the April 30 Activist’s Diary. https://berkeleydailyplanet.com/issue/2023-05-08/article/50289?headline=A-BERKELEY-ACTIVIST-S-DIARY-week-ending-April-30--Kelly-Hammargren
I skipped the Landmarks Preservation Commission. There were two demolition items which could be guaranteed to be approved and another on the color of paint for a historical building.
The Community for a Cultural Civic Center (CCCC) met for a debrief after the City Council vote to approve the Civic Center Plan Phase II including a full evaluation of daylighting Strawberry Creek. The Strawberry Creek culvert runs underneath the Maudelle Shirek Building. The group promoting daylighting the creek has already been invited to submit a full grant application for funding. Just how the rest of the project will be financed is up in the air.
Moving on, the takeaway from the Police Accountability Board Fair and Impartial Policing Subcommittee on August 7 is that the three-pronged approach to traffic stop policing, which places the focus on Vision Zero (zero severe injury and fatal accidents), is not making the expected difference in reducing/eliminating disparate treatment of Black and Brown persons. Implicit bias appears to continue,with a need for further review of community service calls and suspicious vehicle stops.
Only three members of the Commission on Disability attended the August 9 meeting. There are four commission vacancies and four of the five current commissioners were appointed in April and May of this year. Commissioners Sun and Walsh (the only member with several years on the commission) were absent. Thomas Gregory, the Commission Secretary, is also new with only 4 months as a City of Berkeley employee.
A letter from a Berkeley resident to former Councilmember Droste and the commission was in the meeting packet, calling out Droste for using accessibility and ADA compliance as an issue for supporting the new Willard Park Clubhouse plans and involving other city commissions, but not the Commission on Disability.
The new commissioners were not involved, and likely did not know that at the Agenda Committee meetings, starting on June 15, 2020 when the Agenda Committee referred to itself the Commission Reorganization authored by Droste and co-sponsored by Councilmembers Kesarwani and Robinson (Mayor Arreguin joined later), that the proposed plan was to continue with only those commissions and boards required by law, charter, city ordinance and/or ballot initiatives. That would have eliminated the Commission on Disability.
With Droste as the author of the reorganization, it is no surprise that the Commission on Disability was not consulted. Additionally, since the Willard Park Community Center is planned around children and later discussions on commission mergers suggested combing the Commissions on Aging and Disability into one, it further dismisses these commissions from contributing to the planning, even though there are children with disabilities and their parents, grandparents or caregivers may have disabilities.
It was finally decided in 2021 and 2022,as the commission mergers and eliminations moved forward, not to merge Aging and Disability in the first commission reorganization round, but to come back to further reductions later. Councilmember Hahn, Agenda Committee member, was a vocal contributor to the slicing and dicing of commissions.
Much is made of making streets and intersections safe for pedestrians and persons with disabilities with little thought to engaging the Commission on Disability. That might be about to change. The new Commission Secretary is working on bringing project presentations to the Commission before they are set in cement. Then we could hear from the Commission on Disability on things like whether persons in wheelchairs really find it safe and desirable to ride in a bike lane in the street, as suggested by a Transportation and Infrastructure Commissioner on January 19, 2023.
It didn’t look like The Zoning Adjustment Board (ZAB) would vote for Board member Igor Tregub’s substitute motion on the approval of 2147 San Pablo to include cleaning up the approval language to specify that monthly transit passes were for each bedroom and to recommend bird-safe glass, native plantings and compliance with the Hard Hat Ordinance. 2147 San Pablo is a SB 330 State Density Bonus project which means that it complies only with whatever ordinances were in effect when the application was filed.
That means there is no native plantings requirement, the Bird-Safe Ordinance went into effect after application and the Hard Hat Ordinance is still up in the air. ZAB member Brandon Yung liked the virtual signaling, but others vocalized their objections to making recommendations. In the end it passed 5 to 2. Kathleen Crandall who was subbing for the evening abstained and Debra Sanderson voted no.
The other surprise of the evening was that after extended discussion, ZAB continued 1515 Derby, which adds a 3-story single family residence behind the current single family home. While only the house was before ZAB for approval, the plans included adding an ADU later. The discussion (and neighborhood objections) revolved around decreasing the impact to neighbors by swapping the placement of the house and the ADU.
All for now.