The plight of hundreds of thousands of displaced Palestinians, now in Rafah, waiting for hours in line for minimal food, paints a distressing picture. The severe backlog of aid trucks at the Rafah border crossing in Egypt, waiting for weeks to enter Gaza, further exacerbates the crisis. British Foreign Secretary David Cameron's plea for Israel to lift barriers on delivering humanitarian aid underscores the real and widespread hunger faced by the people in Gaza. 

One crucial point that requires immediate attention is the violation of international humanitarian law. The intentional obstruction of essential supplies, such as water and food, raises serious concerns. The recent statement by Scottish MP Brendan O'Hara, questioning Israel's actions in turning off water supplies and the potential breach of international humanitarian law, deserves thorough investigation and international scrutiny. 

It is disheartening to witness such suffering in a region just an hour's drive away, where the provision of humanitarian assistance should not be a challenging task. The obstacles imposed by Israel, such as restricting the entry of trucks and withholding logistical support, hinder the delivery of much-needed aid to the Gaza population. 

This crisis is not solely a consequence of recent events; it has been exacerbated by the long-standing Israeli blockade on Gaza, which has endured for almost 17 years. The decisions to cut off electricity, water supply, and restrict the movement of international humanitarian supplies have created an almost impossible situation for basic services like bakeries to operate. 

The international community must unite to address this urgent humanitarian crisis. Immediate action is needed to ensure the unimpeded delivery of aid, the restoration of essential services, and the respect for international humanitarian law. It is our collective responsibility to prevent a humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza.

The COVID-19 virus continues to claim at least 1,200 lives each week. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data show the latest surge continued nationally through the final week of 2023. The surge is attributed to holiday gatherings, travel and the newly identified JN.1 coronavirus variant.  

COVID-19 hospitalizations in the United States rose by nearly 17%, totaling 29,059 new patients, marking the highest recorded data since January 2022. In the last week of December 2023, there were 78,905 emergency department admissions for COVID-19 and 136,668 for influenza, marking respective increases of 72% and 225% from the previous month. 

The Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine has been available under emergency use authorization (EUA) in individuals16 years of age and older since December 11, 2020, and the authorization was expanded to include those 12 through 15 years of age on May 10, 2021. Yet as of Dec. 8, 2024, only about 17.2% of adults and 8% of children nationwide had received the updated COVID-19 shot, according to the CDC. About 40% of children and adults have received this year’s influenza shot, while just 15.9% of older adults eligible for the RSV vaccine have received it.  

After some three years after the availability of vaccine, here’s why COVID-19 still with us in such force:  

According to a Report Public Policy and Health in the Trump Era from the Lancet Commissions, about 40% of the United States' COVID-19 deaths could have been avoided.  

"Instead of galvanizing the U.S. populace to fight the pandemic, President Trump publicly dismissed its threat (despite privately acknowledging it), discouraged action as infection spread, and eschewed international cooperation. His refusal to develop a national strategy worsened shortages of personal protective equipment and diagnostic tests. President Trump politicized mask-wearing and school re-openings and convened indoor events attended by thousands, where masks were discouraged and physical distancing was impossible." 

The anti-vaccine movement (anti-vaxxers) also share much of the blame, spreading misinformation, pseudoscience, and conspiracy theories. As a result there is still a lingering mistrust of science, leading to a distrust of vaccines and other proven public health measures.  

As a result of our inadequate early response to the pandemic, COVID-19 is here to stay. Similar to the seasonal influenza virus, it is expected to continue to mutate over time. 

My wife and I have all available vaccines. Do you?;

The Berkeley Daily Planet has learned that UC Berkeley Chancellor Carol Christ has cancelled two scheduled Monday appearances at social clubs in the city of Berkeley. She was scheduled to speak tomorrow afternoon at the Town and Gown Club, a long-time city institution founded in 1898 to bring local and Cal-affiliated women together, though current members are more likely to be “bridge and tunnel” suburbanites. In the evening at 7:30, she was supposed to appear before members of the Hillside Club, a Northside group formed early in the 20th Century by advocates for environmentally sensitive development in the Berkeley Hills.

A member of the Hillside Club board told me that they received a phone call from an online police reporter who warned that some activists were claiming that there would be hostile demonstrations at their meeting due to Christ’s vigorous pursuit of the demolition of People’s Park. They told me that many of their members were old and feeble and might be intimidated by this, so they decided to postpone her talk. My contact at Town and Gown told me that after similar warnings they’d changed their lecture to a members-only Zoom.

Approximately simultaneously Christ’s PR aide informed Hillside that the chandellor had decided to bail. Evidently she was surprised that many Berkeleyans were unhappy with the civic anger the Park situation has elicited.

Who knew?

Worth Noting:

City Council is on winter recess through January 15, 2024. The City Council agenda for January 16 is available for comment and follows the list of meetings by day of the week.

• Monday:
  • At 5:30 pm the Human Welfare and Community Action Commission meets in person. Agenda includes reverse mortgage and Fire Chief’s report.
  • At 6:30 pm the Youth Commission meets in person.
  • At 7 pm the Peace and Justice Commission meets in person. Agenda includes a proposal for a panel on peace and justice in Israel and Palestine.
  • At 7 pm the Personnel Board meets in person.
• Wednesday:
  • At 5 pm the Commission on Disability meets in person.
  • From 5:30 – 6:30 pm there is a webinar on individual artist project grants. Use link in calendar to register.
  • At 6:30 pm the Police Accountability Board meets in the hybrid format.
  • At 7 pm the Homeless Panel of Experts meets in person.
  • At 7 pm the Parks, Recreation and Waterfront Commission meets in person. Agenda includes parking study and update on the Waterfront Plan.
• Thursday:
  • From 4:30 – 5:30 pm there is a free Dance Fitness Series at the Wellness Center. Use link to register.
  • At 6:30 pm the Board of Library Trustees meets in person.
  • At 7 pm the Zoning Adjustment Board meets in the hybrid format.
  • The Mental Health Commission usually meets the 2nd Thursday of the month check after Monday for meeting status.
• Friday: From 11 am – 12 pm there is a Webinar on Community festivals. Use link in the calendar to register.
• Saturday: Berkeley Neighborhoods Council usually meets the 2nd Saturday at 10 am on zoom. Check later in the week for the agenda and meeting status.

Directions with links to ZOOM support for activating Closed Captioning and Save Transcript are at the bottom of this calendar.

Check the City website for late announcements and meetings posted on short notice at: https://berkeleyca.gov/

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

BERKELEY PUBLIC MEETINGS AND CIVIC EVENTS 

Sunday, January 7, 2024 – no meetings or events found 

Monday, January 8, 2024 

HUMAN WELFARE and COMMUNITY ACTION COMMISSION at 5:30 pm 

In-Person: 2180 Milvia 

AGENDA: Election of Low-income Representatives, 7. Review City of Berkeley funded agency Program and Financial reports a. J-Sei program and financial reports, 8. Discussion of rights and responsibilities of the HWCAC, 9. Discussion and possible action on holding hybrid commission meetings, 10. Discussion on Public Reverse Mortgage, 11. Discussion of Fire Chief’s Report and Implications. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/human-welfare-and-community-action-commission 

PEACE and JUSTICE at 7 pm 

In-Person: 2939 Ellis, South Berkeley Senior Center 

AGENDA: 8. Proposal for a roundtable/workshop on community action in support of peace with justice in Israel and Palestine, 9. Discussion and Update on the Peace and Justice Merger. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/peace-and-justice-commission 

PERSONNEL BOARD at 7 pm 

In-Person: 1301 Shattuck, Live Oak Community, Creekside Room 

AGENDA: At will designations – Employee Relations Manager and Assistant to the City Attorney. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/personnel-board 

YOUTH COMMISSION at 6:30 pm 

In-Person: 1730 Oregon, Martin Luther King Jr. Youth Services Center/YAP 

AGENDA: 10. Berkeley High School Restroom Survey responses update and create a plan. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/youth-commission 

Tuesday, January 9, 2024 

Wednesday, January 10, 2024 

COMMISSION on DISABILITY at 5 pm 

In-Person: at 1901 Hearst, North Berkeley Senior Center, Dining Room 

AGENDA: 7. Welcome new CoD members, 8. February election of CoD officers, 9. Log of Access Complaints, 10. ADA Coordinator Role and current vacant Director of Public Works positions, 12. Presentation: Tyler Hawes, CivicBell on Virtual speaker Cards, 13. Accessibility of speakers’ lectern at City Council & BUSD meetings, 14. Work Plan, 15. Preferred meeting room, Carried over items: a. Civic Center Subcommittee Briefing, b. Safer pathways map of Berkeley. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/commission-disability 

CIVIC ARTS GRANT WEBINAR: INDIVIDUAL ARTIST PROJECTS from 5:30 – 6:30 pm 

Register: use link 

https://berkeleyca.gov/community-recreation/events/civic-arts-grant-webinar-individual-artist-projects-0 

HOMELESS SERVICES PANEL of EXPERTS at 7 pm 

IN-PERSON: at 1901 Hearst, North Berkeley Senior Center, Juniper Room 

AGENDA: Discussion of the FY 2025- 2028 Community Agency Funding Process, 7. Meeting schedule. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/homeless-services-panel-experts 

PARKS, RECREATION, and WATERFRONT COMMISSION at 7 pm 

In-Person: 2800 Park, Frances Albrier Community Center 

AGENDA: 6. Public comment, 7. Chair’s Report, 8. Director’s Report, Budget, 9. PRW meeting calendar, 10. Inclusionary Playgrounds, 11. Ribbon cutting, APWA women in construction, 12. New City Parks, 13. Trash pickup at parks, 14. Updates to waiver of Berth Fees Reso.66,544-N.S., 15. Upcoming Waterfront Parking Study, Update on Waterfront Specific Plan. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/parks-recreation-and-waterfront-commission 

POLICE ACCOUNTABILITY BOARD at 6:30 pm 

A Hybrid Meeting 

In-Person: at 1901 Hearst, North Berkeley Senior Center 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/82653396072 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 

Meeting ID: 826 5339 6072 

AGENDA: 3. Public comment on agenda and non-agenda items, 4. Minutes, OPDA staff report, Chair and Board reports, 7. Chief of Police Report, 8. Subcommittee reports, 9. Legislative and policy update, CA Legislation/Case Law, City of Berkeley Ordinance, BPD Lexipol Policies, 10. New Business, Nomination for Chair, Vice-Chair, b. Presentation New Policy Complaint 2023-PR-0009, followed with closed session. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/police-accountability-board 

Thursday, January 11, 2024 

 

MOVE YA BODY! Free Dance Fitness Series from 4:30 – 5:30 pm 

In-Person: at 1900 Sixth St, West Berkeley Family wellness Center 

Register: use link 

https://berkeleyca.gov/community-recreation/events/move-ya-body-free-dance-fitness-series 

BOARD OF LIBRARY TRUSTEES Special Meeting at 6:30 pm 

(Agenda states Thursday, January 11, 2024) 

In Person: at 1125 University, West Branch Library 

AGENDA: Action Calendar: III. A. Strategic Plan Adoption, B. Proposed Personnel Budget FY 2025-26 – Library Tax Fund 

https://www.berkeleypubliclibrary.org/about/board-library-trustees 

MENTAL HEALTH COMMISSION is published as meeting the 2nd Thursday of the month at 7 pm. No agenda/meeting announcement is posted. Check for meeting status after Monday. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/mental-health-commission 

ZONING ADJUSTMENT BOARD at 7 pm 

A Hybrid Meeting 

In-Person: at 1231 Addison St. in the School District Board Room 

Videoconference: https://us06web.zoom.us/j/86410805900 

Teleconference: 1-669-44-9171 or 1-699-900-6833  

Meeting ID: 864 1080 5900 

AGENDA: 2. 2420 Shattuck – on consent request to continue to date uncertain – Use Permit #ZP2023-0008 – demolish 2 existing 2-story commercial buildings, merge 2 lots, and construct 17 story (181 feet) 77,733 sq ft mixed-use building with 132 dwelling units (including 14 very low-income density bonus units) 2,314 sq ft ground floor commercial SB 330 project 

3. 2110 McKinley – on consent – Use Permit #ZP2023-0146 – raise the single-family dwelling by 3 ft that exceeds the maximum allowed lot 

4. 2113-2115 Kittredge – on action staff recommend approve – Use Permit # ZP2022-01444 – demolish commercial building on a landmarked site (preserving the front façade former California movie theater) and construct 18-story (203 feet with 8 ft, 4 in parapet) 160,734 sq ft, mixed-use building with 211 dwelling units (including 22 very low income density bonus qualifying units) and a 24,273 sq ft live theater space. SB 330 project. 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/boards-commissions/zoning-adjustments-board 

Friday, January 12, 2024 

CIVIC ARTS GRANT WEBINAR” COMMUNITY FESTIVALS from 11 am – 12 pm 

Register: use link 

https://berkeleyca.gov/community-recreation/events/civic-arts-grant-webinar-community-festivals 

Saturday, January 13, 2024 

BERKELEY NEIGHBORHOODS COUNCIL at 10 am 

Videoconference:  

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/4223188307?pwd=dFlNMVlVZ2d6b0FnSHh3ZlFwV2NMdz09 

Teleconference: 1-669-444-9171 Meeting ID: 422 318 8307 Passcode: 521161 

AGENDA: No agenda posted, check later in week 

https://berkeleyneighborhoodscouncil.com/ 

Sunday, January 14, 2024 - no meetings or events found 

+++++++++++++++++++ 

 

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA for Regular 6 pm Meeting on January 16, 2024 

Hybrid Meeting 

In-Person: at 1231 Addison St. in the School District Board Room 

Videoconference: https://cityofberkeley-info.zoomgov.com/j/1619411775 

Teleconference: 1-669-254-5252 or 1-833-568-8864 (toll free)  

Meeting ID: 161 941 1775 

https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/city-council/city-council-agendas 

AGENDA on CONSENT: 

1. 2nd reading FY 2024 Annual Appropriations Ordinance No. 7,892-N.S. $270355,759 (gross) and $258,134,257 (net)
2. Minutes for Approval
3. Radu, CM Office - Grant $60,000 All animals Grant Award from Koret Shelter Medicine Program at UC Davis
4. Radu, CM Office – Amend Contract No. R9710 with City of Piedmont for Animal services. City of Piedmont will pay the City of Berkeley $196,572 for services performed from FY 2024 – FY 2026, revised maximum $708,388
5. Radu, CM Office – Extension of Declaration of Homeless Shelter Crisis to January 17, 2029
6. Hollander, Economic Development – Grant $30,000 Accept Grant from the National Endowment for the Arts for a new Civic Arts grant program totaling $60,000 to begin in FY 2025
7. Oyekanmi, Finance – Formal Bid Solicitations $3,434,341, Advanced Medical Response Unit $525,000, Towing Services $90,000, Ohlone Park Restroom and Lighting T1 Funds $966,200, Lorin & Gilman Parking Benefit District(s) Formation Services, Fleet Vehicle Washing Services $300,000, Mental health support and consultation services for home visiting and case management $100,000
8. Warhuus, HHCS – Contract $70,000 with Healthy Black Families for Housing Preference Policy Outreach and Education from 1/17/2024 – 1/17/2025
9. Warhuus, HHCS – Amend Contract No. 32300203 add $73,060 total $172,600 with Hansine Fisher & Associates for Targeted Race Management (TCM) from 7/1/2023 – 6/30/2024
10. Warhuus, HHCS – Amend Contract No. 32300134 Bonita House for Specialized Care Unit Provider add $11,500 of State Crisis Care Mobile Units (CCMU) grant funding total $4,579,500
11. Warhuus, HHCS – Revenue Contract $920,557 with BUSD to conduct first aid services at BHS Health Center 7/1/2023 – 6/30/2028
12. Kouyoumdjian, Human Resources - Correct Effective Date for Salary Range Adjustments from 1/1/2023 to 12/1/2022 for Senior Building Maintenance Supervisor, Senior Equipment Supervisor, Senior Public Works Supervisor and Senior Solid Waste Supervisor amenda Resolutions No. 70,993-N.S.
13. Fong, IT – Amend Contract No. 32200162-1 $230,000 total $275,000 with ThirdWave Corporation for Professional Services through 6/30/2025
14. Fong, IT – Amend Contract No. 32100080 add $270,000 total $757,249 with Assetworks LLC Software Modules and Professional Services to provide additional modules and professional services and extend through December 2028
15. Ferris, Parks - Grant Application for $535,000 to Caltrans Sustainable Transportation Grant Program for I80 at Aquatic Park Tide Tube Renovation Project
16. Ferris, Parks – Grant Application to Cal Fire Wildfire Prevention Grants Program to mitigate hazardous tree conditions at Berkeley overnight camps
17. Ferris, Parks – 3 Contracts total $162,000 for As-needed Derelict Vessel and Debris Removal and Disposal Services 1/17/2024 – 1/16/2026, 1. Lind Marine $162,000, 2. Power Engineering Construction $162,000m 3. Silverado Contractors $162,000
18. Klein, Planning - Adopt 1st reading Prevailing Wage Requirements in the Southside Plan Area add BMC 13.108 for projects exceeding 50 units or 50,000 sq ft
19. Wong, Auditor – Contract $100,000 with Ethico for Whistleblower Hotline and Case Management Services from 2/1/2023 – 1/31/2027

Council Consent Items: 

20. Arreguin & Kesarwani (authors), co-sponsors Hahn, Wengraf – RFP for Development of West Berkeley Service Center at 1900 Sixth Street
21. Bartlett, co-sponsor Hahn – Relinquishment of funds for Black History Month Event to Juneteenth Association, Inc 501(c)3
22. Hahn, co-sponsor Robinson – Support Installation Permanent Chess/Games Tables on Telegraph and Propose Resolution of Concerns at 2454 Telegraph
23. Hahn, Co-sponsor Humbert, Bartlett, Arreguin – Install 3-way Stop at the Intersection of Hopkins and McGee
24. Wengraf, co-sponsor Hahn, Kesarwani – Resolution Support of City of Berkeley for Proposition 1
25. Robinson & Harrison authors, co-sponsor Hahn – Referral to City Manager for Policies to Accommodate Chess

ACTION CALENDAR: 

26. Hollander, Economic Development – Expansion of the Elmwood Business Improvement District (BID) Levy Assessments in the District for 2025 and Authorize a Contract with Elmwood Business Association (EBA) to receive revenue
27. Kouyoumdjian, Human Resources – Amending the Miscellaneous CalPERS Contract to (a) Eliminate PEPRA Cost Sharing for Unrepresented Employee (b) Add Paramedic and Limited Term EMT to Safety Category
28. Cardwell, CM Office – Consideration for BHS Staff Parking
29. Robinson, Bartlett & Taplin (authors) – Neighborhood-Scale Commercial
30. Harrison – (to be moved to consent to reschedule to date certain) Adopt Ordinance adding BMC 12.75 to Establish Protections Relating to Horses Held, Owned, Used, Exhibited or Otherwise Kept for Racing or Other Sport Entertainment or Profit

INFORMATION REPORTS: 

31. Friedrichsen, Budget Manager – FY 2023 Preliminary Year-End Status

++++++++++++++++++++++ 

LAND USE CALENDAR PUBLIC HEARINGS: 

• 2924 Russell 2/27/2024
• 1960 San Antonio 645 Arlington Avenue 2/13/2024
• 3000 Shattuck Avenue (Construct 10-story mixed-use building) – TBD

WORK SESSIONS & SPECIAL MEETINGS: 

• January 23, 2024 – Re-Imagining Public Safety Update (special meeting)
• January 30 at 3 pm – Ashby BART TOD (Tentative)
• February 6, 2024 – Office of Economic Development (OED) Dashboards Presentation
• February 6, 2024 - Draft Waterfront Specific Plan (tentative) – rescheduled from November 2, 2023)

UNSCHEDULED WORK SESSIONS & SPECIAL MEETINGS 

• Fire Department Standards of Coverage & Community Risk Assessment - (removed)
• Dispatch Needs Assessment Presentation
• Presentation on Homelessness/Re-Housing/Thousand-Person Plan (TBD regular agenda)

PAST MEETINGS with reports worth reading: 

• May 16 - Fire Facilities Study Report, Wildfire Prevention Plan https://berkeleyca.gov/city-council-special-meeting-eagenda-may-16-2023-6-pm
• June 20 (WS) - Climate Action Plan & Resilience Update, Berkeley Economic Dashboards Update reports available https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/city-council/city-council-agendas/city-council-2023-06-20

. 

* * * * * 

Kelly Hammargren’s summary on what happened the preceding week is posted on the What Happened page at: https://www.sustainableberkeleycoalition.com/what-happened.html and in the Berkeley Daily Planet https://www.berkeleydailyplanet.com/ 

 

The Activist’s Calendar of meetings is posted on the What’s Ahead page at: https://www.sustainableberkeleycoalition.com/whats-ahead.html 

 

If you would like to receive the Activist’s Calendar as soon as it is completed send an email to: kellyhammargren@gmail.com.If you want to receive the Activist’s Diary send an email to kellyhammargren@gmail.com. If you wish to stop receiving the weekly calendar of city meetings please forward the email you received to- kellyhammargren@gmail.com -with the request to be removed from the email list. 

______________ 

For Online Public Meetings 

CLOSED CAPTIONING, SAVE TRANSCRIPT OVERVIEW, DIRECTIONS and ZOOM SUPPORT LINKS:
.
ZOOM has as part of the program -(for no extra cost)- Closed Captioning (CC). It turns computer voice recognition into a text transcript. Closed Captioning and show full transcript and the save option are only available when the person setting up the ZOOM meeting has activated these options. If you don’t see CC ask for it. If it can’t be activated for the current meeting ask for it for future meetings. 

The accuracy of the Closed Captioning is affected by background noise and other factors, The CC and transcript will not be perfect, but most of the time reading through it the few odd words, can be deciphered--for example "Shattuck" was transcribed as Shadow in one recent transcript. 

For the online attendee, the full transcript is only available from the time the attendee activates Show Full Transcript. But if you sit through a meeting and then remember 10 minutes before it is over to click on Show Full Transcript you will only get the last 10 minutes, not the full transcript – So click often on both Save Transcript and on Save to Folder during the meeting for best results. 

 

When you click on Show Full Transcript it will allow you to scroll up and down, so if want to go back and see what was said earlier you can do that during the meeting while the transcript is running. 

 

At the bottom of the transcript when we as attendees are allowed to save there will be a button for, "Save Transcript," you can click on the button repeatedly throughout the meeting and it will just overwrite and update the full transcript. Clicking on the Save Transcript repeatedly as the meeting is coming to an end is important because once the host ends the meeting, the transcript is gone if you didn't save it. 

 

Near the end of the meeting, after you click on "Save Transcript," click on "Save to Folder." The meeting transcript will show up (as a download to your desktop) in a separate box as a text file. (These text files are not large.) After you have done your last Save Transcript and Save to Folder (after the meeting is over) you can rename the new transcript folder on your computer, and save it (re-read or send or share it). 

 

Remember, allowing us attendees to save the meeting transcript does not require the public meeting host to save the transcript (for public record.) 

 

Here is the link to ZOOM Support for how to set up Closed Captioning for a meeting or webinar:
https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/8158738379917#h_01GHWATNVPW5FR304S2SVGXN2X 

 

Here is the link to ZOOM Support for attendees in how to save Closed Captions: 

https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/360060958752-Using-save-captions#h_01F5XW3BGWJAKJFWCHPPZGBD70 

How to convert a YouTube video into a transcript 

Copy the YouTube url into the box with “enter a youtube url” and click on go https://youtubetranscript.com/ 

The transcript (not perfect, but very close) will appear instantaneously 

Hundreds of Jewish activists and their allies shut down the California state Capitol in Sacramento Wednesday during its first floor session of the new year, to demand a ceasefire in Gaza. Anti-Zionist organizer and former IDF soldier from Tel Aviv Meital Yaniv, who joined hundreds of Jewish activists and their allies to shut down the California state Capitol in Sacramento Wednesday to demand a ceasefire in Gaza and condemn the roughly $600 million in California taxes that is used annually for U.S. military aid to Israel. Yaniv recalls how they were raised “extremely Zionistic,” their experience in the Israeli Air Force and eventually turned to fight for Palestinian rights. “What Israel is doing right now has nothing to do with antisemitism. What Israel is doing right now is a genocide. What Israel has been doing for the past 75 years is apartheid, is occupation,” Yaniv says. “There is no need for any one of us to serve in the IDF. The IDF should not exist

Dear Councilmember Humbert:

I understand that you also are an attorney. I practiced law in Washington state for 25 years. As a Cal alum (Class of 1982), I am grateful for my academic and social education at UC Berkeley. I was an elected ASUC Senator, a member of Berkeley Students for Peace, Students Against Intervention in El Salvador, and actively involved in the UC Divestment campaign to end Apartheid in South Africa. I was also involved in the Interfaith community- and worked as the Director of Hunger Education and Action at Unitas (now Free House) in my gap year before USF Law School.

I’m also a supporter of the historic, internationally recognized Commons, the 2.8 acre parcel of land that is known as People’s Park. I along with many others helped build the Free Speech Stage in 1979. I’ve also attended dozens of peaceful, joyful events in the park since my return to Berkeley in 2010. It is a space where diverse groups of people of all ages and backgrounds danced, sang, played music, gardened and held classes, tours for tourists, meetings, and individual conversations about life, current events, traveling, culture, etc.

It is tragic that people have died in People’s Park. The answer to that problem is prevention programs and more support to outreach teams to reduce harm and protect everyone from deadly drugs. We had four deaths in one day from fentanyl in Dr. King Civic Center Park last year, but that was not grounds to close the park. Park supporters are also continually working on keeping people safe - and definitely are proponents for public safety. Have you talked with any of the peace activists connected to the park, or attended any concerts or festivals before the COVID shutdown?

The answer also is to provide supportive housing, which could be provided on six other ‘opportunity sites’ identified by the 2021 UC Long Range Development Plan. If you have not done so, I encourage you to do as I did- read the entire 400 plus page report. I also participated in public comment at UC Regents meetings.

It is an erroneous label to call park supporters ‘anti-housing.’ I have been advocating for affordable housing in Berkeley for the last 13 years: I attended Planning Commision, ZAB, Council and other meetings. The council refused to set aside 20% BMR units despite the city’s own Nexus study confirming that developers would meet their ROI (they could ‘pencil it out’ in terms of profit). Both the City and University have failed to meet the urgent need for affordable housing. Our RHNA numbers are met over 200% for upper income and zero for very low income persons. Our crisis is horrible and preventable. I trust and hope that you will urge developers to do more including by passing a Community Benefits Ordinance.

Also, it was not clear to me that many Berkeley City Council members read the court opinion that suspended construction on People’s Park. Sadly, the council voted to submit an Amicus brief in support of the University. I read the entire opinion and it is based on a sound, rational analysis of the UC’s failure to identify mitigation of adverse environmental impacts, and its failure to consider and discuss alternative sites (which would actually provide many more housing units for students than the proposal for People’s Park).

The city and my alma mater have unleashed a dangerous and troubling situation. I witnessed very peaceful protestors when I was in People’s Park at midnight - early Thursday morning when unmarked white vans pulled up to the park filled with armed police officers. On Friday, I spoke with young people who witnessed a kid smashed to the ground by police (she apparently was treated at the hospital and may have a broken collar bone as a result). I witnessed an officer in the park attempt to rush up to a college student with baton forward - the young man was just standing there asking for his badge number that had been covered up. Another officer pulled the aggressive officer back. We have over 500 officers in our city in riot gear contributing to much anxiety and tension.

I don’t know if you have read the court materials on the Federal Court case captioned Law v. City of Berkeley - but the evidence and past pattern and practice does not support your statement that BPD is well trained and proficient in de-escalation. In a BlackLivesMatter protest, they escalated and bashed me, a journalist, a minister, and Cal students with hard, painful batons, and threw flash bang grenades at our feet, and later tossed tear gas through the streets including along Telegraph. In discovery, the city admitted dispersing so much of the toxic gas that they did not know the quantity.

h I don’t know if you ever attended any of the beautiful gatherings at People’s Park - but many of us are saddened by the overly aggressive, extremely costly actions (24/7 dining operation for 1,400 people for 4 days?) We could have provided meals for 1,000 unhoused people and 100 hotel vouchers for 6 months to a year probably. And low income housing vouchers for 40% of students at Cal who receive financial aid (Pell Grants provide only $900 a month for housing and UC dorms cost much more than that.. off campus housing is average $1,200- $1,400 a month per student .. many of them don’t have enough money to eat three meals a day - fortunately students started an on campus food bank- I helped start the UC Food Collective that is still going over 40 years later).

It is unfair and misleading to blame peaceful protestors for the university’s failure to provide affordable housing. Please examine all of the evidence- and I appreciate your willingness to investigate misconduct by BPD. They are required to wear body warn cameras as a result of the federal court settlement in Law v. City of Berkeley. And the Reimagining Task Force and Mayor’s Fair and Impartial Policing Task Force that I was appointed to by Mayor Arreguin worked tirelessly to ensure BPD operates within the guidelines of Constitutional Policing. The City Council and City Manager will hopefully ensure Best Practices are applied, and new reforms are being implemented. It has not been our experience - there’s often push back, delay and excuses (including the BPD Bike Patrol racist text scandal).

The other problem with this large military style operation in Berkeley this week is the inability to control police units from a dozen other locations. The ‘Mutual Aid’ operation caused significant harm during the BlackLivesMatter peaceful protest where police were a large part of the rioting behavior (see video online of officers beating people, throwing a young woman on the ground, shooting people with ‘less lethal’ but painful pellets, tear gas, etc).

I am also submitting this letter of concern to the Police Accountability Board.

As you have probably heard, UC Berkeley has begun the process of preparing People’s Park for the addition of student and homeless housing, as well as new park space and features celebrating People’s Park’s history. Sadly, given the protests and sometimes violent actions trying to block this project, the University has also had to take unusual and unfortunate measures to protect the site. With everything that’s going on, I wanted to offer you an update and share my thoughts.

First, I want to reiterate that I strongly support creating new housing and open space at People’s Park. Our city and UC Berkeley both desperately need housing to meet demand, lower rents, and prevent displacement, and Southside is an ideal location for it. In a perfect world, the current form of People’s Park could be a monument to Berkeley’s history, progressive movements, and ideals—but it has failed to fill that role for decades. Instead, the park has witnessed violent crime, lonely deaths, and, shockingly, children being drugged. Past efforts to make it function as a park that is safe and welcoming for all have been violently opposed by many of the same people now fighting against the new housing. It is in this context that the UC has been forced to take drastic measures just to allow for site preparation to move forward. Some opponents have pointed to the immense cost of securing the site as a reason to abandon housing at this location. But these costs only exist because a vocal and at times violent minority has decided that their views matter more than the will of the public. Housing opponents trying to impose their will by protesting and making the cost of housing too high is not democracy. Indeed, they are tactics used by housing opponents for decades.

It was just a couple of years ago that housing opponents proved that they were willing to violently storm the site and destroy equipment. This needless drama and the threat of a repeat are why the UC was compelled to act swiftly and on short notice to shield the site. This included restricting access to key roadways and towing private vehicles near the park. The UC has also been forced to construct a barrier made of shipping containers in order to protect workers and the new housing from those intent on vandalism and violence. I want to commend the UC for the care and foresight they put into their efforts to ready the area. With respect to towing, a hotline was set up, no one was ticketed or charged, all affected people were offered rides to their vehicles and $100 gift card for their trouble. I understand that those living and working around the site are unfortunately still facing great inconvenience when it comes to traveling to and from their homes and workplaces. I call on the UC and various law enforcement agencies charged with protecting the project to be accommodating and courteous in this regard. (If you experience any difficulties, please let my office and the UC know right away.)

With respect to law enforcement involvement, I have seen people express concerns regarding the number of officers and the potential for excessive force. But if we want to avoid the use of potentially problematic crowd control methods, we need a large contingent of officers who can engage in more targeted and tailored enforcement. When it comes to the Berkeley Police Department, I believe BPD has a strong track record and training when it comes to deescalation; but I also want to reiterate that the City takes a hard line against excessive force and any alleged instances will be investigated thoroughly and impartially. By the same token, I also condemn any violence or vandalism by protestors. I am firmly committed to the First Amendment and the right to protest; but that right does not extend to indefinite disruption of other people’s lives and certainly not to physical harm or destruction. Freedom of speech and the practice of civil disobedience are not carte blanche. A key part of nonviolent civil disobedience is accepting that one’s actions may result in arrest. Berkeley and the US have a proud history of civil disobedience, but I want to be crystal clear: I believe that building housing and a new People’s Park is the right thing to do and not something to resist.

Not only does the planned project include over 100 units of permanently affordable supportive housing, but the University also made an extraordinary effort to ensure that everyone who was previously staying at the Park found permanent housing. The social worker hired by the University, City homeless services staff, and local nonprofits have engaged in a tremendous effort to provide assistance, services, and shelter to every person who was previously using the park. I am proud of these efforts, and I think that they reflect the caring and community-minded approach that the City and the University have taken with respect to this project. I appreciate that there are some who will disagree, but I continue to proudly support this new student and homeless housing, and I hope it moves forward swiftly. I ask protestors to work with us to tackle our housing and homelessness challenges. And I hope the California Supreme Court will rule swiftly so that actual construction may begin.

I welcome and look forward to hearing your thoughts, even if we disagree. And please let us know if you need information or assistance regarding this stage of the project, which we hope will be concluded soon.

According to reports in the Daily Cal, on the Berkeleyside website and in private communications with several civic sources, as many as 1400 police officers are expected to come to Berkeley in the next week in anticipation of demonstrations against UC actions to continue a dormitory project on the site of National Register People’s Park. According to Berkeley Community Safety Coalition officer and civic activist Moni Law, Park supporters have been asked to join a preliminary gathering at 11 p.m tonight, Wednesday. Construction equipment is expected to arrive at 4 a.m Thursday, possibly to build a fence around the site while most students are out of town. Councilmember and mayoral candidate Kate Harrison told the Planet that UC workers have been asked to expect to provide 24 hour food service to the law enforcement personnel for at least a week.

I am writing this open letter to you in my individual capacity as a Councilmember because I understand that U.C. plans to use significant police force to secure People’s Park in the coming days. This significant action would occur prior to, and pre-judge, the California Supreme Court’s review of its decision regarding UC’s compliance with state law. 

Please commit that U.C.P.D. and agencies offering mutual aid will follow the City of Berkeley’s rules concerning use of “less-lethal” weapons and tactics—including but not limited to tear gas, pepper spray, smoke, Long-Range Acoustic Devices, batons, rubber bullets, launched projectiles, and corralling—against nonviolent protesters, including those participating in nonviolent civil disobedience. These rules, established to protect human life and people’s first amendment rights, are core to our City’s value. Nor should the City be asked to waive them. 

I am supportive in concept of the University’s original plan to build student and homeless housing at the Park while preserving desperately needed and lacking open space in the Southside Campus area. As of today, it is not clear if that original vision is still possible, as the affordable housing developer of the supportive housing has withdrawn from the project, in large part due to the failure of UC to follow NEPA, resulting in the withdrawal of federal housing subsidies. In the meantime, at its own expense, the City of Berkeley continues to make available scarce homeless housing to relocate existing People Park campers, displacing other Berkeley residents. 

Regardless, even if the project as originally conceived is still possible, it would not be worth the human cost to engage in a brutal, heavy handed police action to make it a reality. This would directly contravene the planned acknowledgement of the critical history of the Park in the civil rights, free speech and open space movements, which placement on the National Register enshrines. 

In response to the murder of George Floyd and the protests and police response that followed, on June 9, 2020, the Berkeley City Council unanimously passed a motion to prohibit the use of tear gas by the Berkeley Police Department or by any agency called for mutual aid in Berkeley. This motion also prohibited the use of pepper spray and smoke by the Berkeley Police Department and by any agency called for mutual aid response in Berkeley, during the COVID-19 pandemic and until such time that the City Council removes this prohibition (which it has not done). 

Unfortunately, U.C.’s Police Policies and Procedures allow U.C. Police Department to apply intermediate force against nonviolent protesters displaying active resistance. The international laws of war prohibit the use of tear gas and pepper spray as chemical weapons; the University has no such restrictions. Use of these so-called “less lethal’ weapons in an indiscriminate manner is a denial of First Amendment rights to free speech and assembly. 

I believe the University’s time, money, and efforts would be better spent delivering student housing at any of the number of undeveloped sites available to it (which have the capacity for an equal or greater number of beds), including parking lots and tennis courts. Additionally, the University should work to re-engage an affordable housing developer for permanent supportive housing at the Park. These are laudable goals that would benefit our entire community and should be pursued before moving ahead. 

However, if you intend to continue your efforts to secure the site despite the existing legal challenges and absence of an affordable developer, at a minimum protesters should not be harmed in order to do so.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation has called for the preservation of People's Park, pointing out that it is “nationally significant for its association with student protests and countercultural activities during the 1960s” and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. 

In a December 2023 letter to the People's Park Historic District Advocacy Group, the National Trust says, “(We wish) to express our support for the full exploration of all potential alternatives that result in the preservation of People’s Park. The exploration of alternatives is a core protection provided to historic places by CEQA.” 

“For projects that are not dependent on a single location, such as the proposed construction of student housing, a robust alternatives analysis can often identify superior win-win solutions that allow both preservation and new construction. We hope that just such a solution can be identified that enables both the construction of new student housing in Berkeley and the preservation of People’s Park,” the letter continues. 

In addition to its historical importance, People's Park is also a valuable piece of public open space in Berkeley's most densely populated neighborhood. Destroying the only piece of public open space in the South Campus area of Berkeley would have many negative impacts and would violate international, national, state and city standards for urban green space.

Bob Lalanne, former UC Berkeley Vice Chancellor for Real Estate (VCRE) notes that “People’s Park was off the table for any development while we were completing a number of dormitory projects previous to me leaving my position in 2016. Many alternative campus-owned housing development sites have been available for decades and remain to this day. The VCRE issued a report to the Chancellor in 2015 and actually requested funds from campus leadership to remodel the park and were denied. 

He continued, “We had looked into adjacent retail properties fronting on Telegraph Avenue, particularly the food retailers that back up to the Park to actually open the rear of their properties to the park for outdoor seating to enliven the Park even more. It is in part due to poor planning and the lack of execution of new student housing by campus for the past 20 years that housing did not keep up with enrollment growth and that the Park is targeted for destruction due to “housing shortage.””  

The National Trust agrees. It supports the "full exploration of all alternatives that result in the preservation of People's Park." Like the People's Park Historic District Advocacy Group, the trust believes it is possible to have a win-win solution that includes "the construction of student housing and the preservation of People's Park." 

The Washington D.C.-based trust, chartered by Congress in 1949, acts "to protect significant historic places and advocate for historical preservation as a fundamental value in programs and policies at all levels of government.” 

The National Trust letter is attached in a pdf file here.

People with psychiatric conditions may have "inappropriate behavior." Yet, many of us, including me, have a lot of resentment over being labeled that way and treated accordingly. People in society at large often reject mentally ill people in a standardized way because many of us could be unaware of the nuances of being social. This is form of intolerance--of someone being different. Thus, we are rejected, excluded, and disdained.  

And this can be heartbreaking. We don't have to be ashamed of ourselves just because a person or persons make us unwelcome and cast judgment on us. We have every right to respect ourselves. We can't force someone else to respect us, but we can value ourselves and think to ourselves "consider the source."  

It is not unusual for a mentally ill person to become unwelcome among a group, among a church, or in the presence of an individual. A person or group of persons may assert that you are bad news and a bad person. You don't have to buy that. On the other hand, if a person is threatening legal or police action, you should heed that warning. If you like yourself enough, it won't be so difficult for you to comply with someone else's wish to have you out of their life. And you don't have to prove that to anyone except yourself. The more weeks, months, and years that you log in as controlling an "inappropriate" behavior, the more confidence you will have. You can enjoy the silent revenge of "living well." In my past, I've had behavior that people considered "inappropriate." And this caused me to become unwelcome among some. "How has he dealt with this?" --you might ask. 

I've reached a stage in my life in which I can continue liking myself, and yet, others do not have to like me. This is an essential life lesson. Not everyone is going to like you, and that's just part of the human condition. If you don't want me at your church, if you don't want my calls, and if you want nothing to do with me, then fine, I'm gone. Does this leave me bitter? At this stage in life, no. I don't need to prove something to those who believed I was bad news. I don't know what goes through other people's heads. I don't know what conversations people have. 

And I don't care. It's not worth it for me to try and make everyone like me, or to try to make anyone other than me believe I am an acceptable person.  

If I ever thought of "payback" toward people in my past, it would be a grave mistake. I would only end up ruining my own life--because any attempt at "settling the score" would backfire. The only channel open to me is that of making my life better for me. 

Learning to let go of a person, place, or thing, is a very valuable skill. If persons with psychiatric difficulties can just learn this skill, it will allow for a better life. Self-approval matters. Parents might withhold approval. Spouses might withhold approval. We must never withhold approval from ourselves. We can't control anyone but ourselves. And sometimes even control of oneself is a very tall order. This is where therapy can help if the therapist is good. 

Psychiatry views us as affected by brain related conditions and tries to help us and manage us through making changes to brain chemistry with pills and shots. But there is value in psychology. Psychology isn't as much of a hard science as psychiatry supposedly is. And some psychologists are bad at it. You should learn to spot a bad psychologist. It is usually the one who thinks it is all about they, the great therapist who just saved another one.  

If a psychologist can show you that you have a good side, a powerful side, a part of you that can make your life and your mind better, then the practitioner is a great mirror that you can use some of the time. Keep in mind that everyone makes mistakes. And when you make a mistake, admit it, but keep liking yourself. Because if you don't like yourself, no one else will. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  

Jack Bragen lives and writes in Martinez, California.

The recent resignation of Harvard University President Claudine Gay marks a disheartening moment for academia, raising critical concerns about the state of higher education. As the first African American and second woman to lead this prestigious institution, her departure amid allegations of plagiarism and backlash over her testimony on antisemitism is deeply troubling. 

The circumstances surrounding Gay's resignation are concerning, with allegations of plagiarism being used as a pretext to oust her. This seems to be part of a larger trend—an assault on education and an attempt to silence voices advocating for justice, equality, and Palestinian rights on college campuses. 

Havard professor halil Gibran Muhammad's words resonate strongly. This isn't merely about accusations of plagiarism; it's about a broader right-wing agenda targeting education's progress on race, gender, and addressing inequality. Such attacks undermine the fundamental values of scholarly rigor and diversity, creating an environment where personal attacks and racial animus overshadow an individual's commitment to combat hate and uphold academic integrity. 

The campaign against Gay, spearheaded by conservative forces and amplified through personal attacks, threats, and unfounded allegations, points to a distressing reality. The resignation of both Claudine Gay and University of Pennsylvania President Elizabeth Magill following a congressional hearing raises concerns about the chilling effect on academic freedom and integrity. 

It's crucial to note that these allegations of plagiarism have been contested by Gay's thesis adviser, Gary King, who attests to the high academic standards met in her work. The support Gay received from the Harvard Corporation, acknowledging her resilience amidst sustained attacks, emphasizes the unfairness of the situation she faced. 

This situation warrants reflection on the increasing politicization of academia, where educational institutions become battlegrounds for ideological conflicts rather than spaces for learning, discourse, and progress. It's imperative to safeguard academic freedom, protect diverse perspectives, and resist attempts to stifle important conversations on campus. 

The resignation of Claudine Gay underscores the urgent need to address these systemic challenges facing higher education. It's a call to action for all stakeholders to defend the values of academic rigor, diversity, and inclusion, ensuring that our universities remain bastions of knowledge, free thought, and progress

There was only one Berkeley City meeting in this first week of January 2024, the Agenda and Rules Committee. With a three- member committee, all of whom have publicly declared their opposition to a ceasefire resolution in the Israel-Hamas war, it did not take any imagination to know what would not be on the agenda for the first city council meeting after winter recess on January 16. The three Councilmembers, Bartlett, Robinson and Taplin,who each posted their own version of a ceasefire resolution on X (formerly Twitter), folded under pressure and never submitted them. Taplin’s proposed resolution called for an end to hostilities,which I characterized as too timid in a previous Activist’s Diary given the conditions in Gaza. 

Committee member Councilmember Susan Wengraf, who is retiring in 2024, was absent from the meeting, which barely made the 24-hour posting requirement. The current Mayor, Jesse Arreguin, State Senate hopeful, and current Councilmember Sophie Hahn, who hopes to be anointed by the voters in 2024 to replace Arreguin as mayor, were present to finalize the agenda. 

The January 16th agenda has items like adding 3-way stop signs at McGee and Hopkins (a good idea), funding a real bathroom to replace the porta potty at Ohlone Park, admitting there is a long term Homeless Shelter Crisis with a declaration that forecasts a shelter crisis end on January 17, 2029, adopting the first reading of the prevailing wage requirements in the Southside for projects with more than 50 units or 50,000 square feet and continuing the clean-up of the City of Berkeley’s failure in the handling of union contracts on CalPERS and PEPRA (retirement funding). 

Councilmember Harrison’s proposed ordinance related to racehorses will go through another review by the City Attorney. The only expected action on January 16 on the conditions regarding horses for racing and sports is to move that item to consent to be rescheduled to a date certain. 

In the agenda/ non-agenda comment period at the beginning of the meeting, nine speakers called for the Berkeley City Council to vote for a ceasefire, to which there was no response from either Arreguin or Hahn. 

By the time this Diary is finished and published we will have an answer from the San Francisco Board of Supervisors on their response to their Ceasefire Resolution. The weekend news announced San Francisco Supervisors will take public comment on Monday and vote on Tuesday.  

[The SF Supes on Tuesday voted to support a modified ceasefire resolution, backed by Berkeley High graduate Supervisor Aaron Peskin.] 

When it came time to comment on Discussion and Possible Action on City Council Rules of Decorum, two of the regular Agenda Committee attendees expressed their distress and being appalled by the behavior and disruption at city council meetings by the people calling for a Ceasefire Resolution from the Berkeley City Council. 

There is desperation in the voices of the people coming to council meetings pleading for Berkeley to join other cities backing a cease fire resolution. The desperation here is nothing compared to the horror in Gaza. 

The death toll as month four of that war begins is around 23,000 with the deaths of children numbering over 10,000. That approximation is only those whose bodies can be counted. How many are under the rubble in unknown. 

To put the deaths of children in Gaza in a broader perspective. Gaza has a population around 2.2 million. In Ukraine with a population of a little under 44 million an estimated 1800 children have died in the nearly two years since the Russian invasion in February 2022. 

We are watching a genocide in Gaza. 

Israel’s blockade of food, water and supplies and medicines continues. 

The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) emergency relief chief Martin Griffiths said this: “Gaza has simply become uninhabitable…The humanitarian community has been left with the impossible mission of supporting more than 2 million people even as its own staff are being killed and displaced, as communication blackouts continue, as roads are damaged and convoys are shot at, and as commercial supplies vital to survival are almost non-existent”. 

Please read Griffiths’ full statement from January 5, 2024. https://www.unocha.org/publications/report/occupied-palestinian-territory/war-gaza-must-end-statement-martin-griffiths-under-secretary-general-humanitarian-affairs-and-emergency-relief-coordinator-5-january-2024-enhear 

Children in Gaza with such devastating injuries that their limbs have to be amputated are reduced to suffering that was common in the American Civil War 170 years ago, surgeries without anesthesia. All this is because of the Israeli blockade and relentless bombardment. 

It is only because of dedicated journalists facing constant threat of death that the news reaches us. Somewhere between 79 and 110 journalists and media workers have been killed, depending on which news source is referenced. Al Jazeera accused Israel of targeted killing of two of their journalists on Sunday. 

The desperation in the voices of those coming to council and showing up on the street might best be interpreted as meaning that there are still some who hold shreds of hope that if enough people demonstrate somehow the killing of children, their parents and families in this war will stop. 

Trita Parsi had this to say on Democracy Now: “I think the Biden administration made a huge miscalculation from the outset. They did not think there would be this type of backlash amongst the American public, including Biden’s own supporters, against the Israeli campaign…it appears that the conclusion in the White House is that they have already lost these votes…if they shift their position they will likely lose some of the voters that are in support of Israel’s Campaign”. 

This kind of calculation sounds like the retired generals who come on mainstream media programs to talk about war strategies with a detachment that disregards the lives and pain on the ground. 

If this continues as Prime Minister Netanyahu promises, and President Biden fails to use his leverage to end this war (It is American weapons, munitions and tax dollars that are used in the killing and maiming of civilians in Gaza), speeches on saving democracy to win reelection in 2024 pale before the horror of it all. 

Now that two states Colorado (through the courts) and Maine (by Secretary of the State) have barred former President Trump from the primary ballot and stayed their decisions pending an appeal to the Supreme Court, the TV pundits on MSNBC and CNN have wrapped themselves into knots commenting on everything except the last sentence of Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. 

I happen to keep a copy of the Constitution on my desk, but you can pull it up with your browser to read Section 3 for yourself. 

Section 3. No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice-President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any state, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any State legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any State, to support the Constitution of the United states, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. But Congress may by vote of two-thirds of each House, remove such disability. [emphasis added] 

I’m not sure that I would trust Congress any more than I trust the Supreme Court. Would all the Democrats or at least enough still hold to prevent a two-thirds vote? The belief that Biden would do best in his bid for reelection against Trump is a risky position. 

As the clamor grows, especially but not exclusively on the Republican side, that the voters should choose the President, has everyone ignored or forgotten that most dictators are elected? At least that is what the historians tell us. 

Hitler was elected. Mussolini was elected in 1921 to the lower chamber of Italy’s parliament, the Chamber of Deputies, before seizing power through the armed march on Rome in 1922 demanding to be named prime minister. 

The story of Trump wanting to go to the capitol on January 6 reminded me of the descriptions of Mussolini’s march on Rome with his paramilitary Blackshirts. Trump had his militias the Oathkeepers, the Three Percenters, the violent far right Islamophobic, misogynistic hate group the Proud Boys and his true believers to fill out the mob. 

Former Congresswoman Liz Cheney (R-Wyoming) gave the warning the U.S. is “sleepwalking into dictatorship” earlier this year. (I am still on the wait list for her book at the Berkeley Library) 

If we are really going to hold to the 14th Amendment Section 3, there were eight Senators and one hundred thirty-nine Representatives who voted after the insurrection against certifying the election of President Biden. Their action is more ambiguous. It might be asked whether their vote against the certification of Biden as President after the insurrection fell into “given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof”. With nearly every one of these 147 still in Congress (only a couple of representatives have left), they are still present to make trouble the next time around. And some of those elected Senators and Representatives actively participated in the planning of schemes to keep Trump in office. 

Having just finished reading The Shadow Docket: How the Supreme Court Uses Stealth Rulings to Amass Power and Undermine the Republic by Steve Vladeck, I have little faith the Supreme Court will do anything other than ensure that Trump is on the ballot, though they do have an out: following the 14th Amendment and sending the decision to Congress. 

Some months ago, when I was out gathering signatures to support daylighting the creek in Martin Luther King Civic Center Park. I stopped to have a long conversation with a student from Stanford. I can’t remember how our conversation drifted to books. What I do remember is his boasting about never reading books. 

While each of us has our stories about how the pandemic affected and changed us, mine was, I started reading with a voracious passion and I haven’t stopped. I also started writing. 

I shared with my Sunday walk partner how grateful I am for our book club. 

I’m into my fourth book on Palestine and Israel Decolonizing Palestine: The Land, The People The Bible by Mitri Raheb with two more started in my reading stack The Hundred Years’ War on Palestine: A History of Settler Colonialism and Resistance, 1917-2017 by Rashi Khalidi and Rise and Kill First: The Secret History of Israel’s Target Assassinations by Ronen Bergman. The three I finished were: Ten Myths About Israel by Ilan Pappe, A Day in the Life of Abed Salama: Anatomy of a Jerusalem Tragedy by Nathan Thrall and The Girl Who Stole My Holocaust: A Memoir by Naom Chayut. 

If you asked if you could read only one, which one would I recommend? That is a hard choice. Decolonizing Palestine is absolutely the clearest. Ethnic cleansing of the Arabs from Palestine was always a plan from the earliest visions in the 1800s. A Day in the Life of Abed Salama expands the tragic bus accident into describing daily life in the West Bank. Chayut’s rambling memoir chronicles his indoctrination into Zionism and the IDF (Israel Defense Forces); how they terrorized Palestinians in the West Bank, pushed them out of their homes, destroyed their possessions, killed innocent Palestinians and shot up property for sport. 

Whatever I thought about Israel decades ago when I was in high school has been washed away by coming to an understanding of Palestine, settler colonization, race and the force I didn’t consider, Christian Zionism. 

Learning From the Germans: Race and the Memory of Evil by Susan Newman (another book I just finished) while focusing on racism and the history of slavery in the United States and Germany’s ongoing working off the past overlaps into the conditions in Israel and Palestine. Neiman is an American who moved to Israel to work and raise her three young children and then to Berlin, Germany in 1982 where she still lives. 

There is so much in the book Learning From the Germans. In Nieman’s comparison between Germany and the United States slavery and the glorification of the lost cause, she writes and asks could we imagine Germany with statues glorifying Hitler? How is it we sit in the U.S. filled with statues honoring the confederacy glorifying confederate generals and soldiers and allow the Civil War portrayed as the “lost cause”? 

It was just December 27, 2023 when Republican presidential candidate Nikki Haley was asked at a town hall in Berlin, New Hampshire what did she believes caused the Civil War. Haley went into a lengthy response about the role of government, “the freedoms of what people could and couldn’t do”, never mentioning slavery. The person who asked the question said he was “astonished” by the response. 

As we crossed the third anniversary of the January 6th insurrection I watched some of the film of that day with the carrying of confederate flags into the capitol.  

As the book comes to a close Neiman writes about leadership. It was 2019. Neiman reminds us it was the racist backlash regarding President Obama, our first Black president, that brought us President Trump in 2016. 

On Christmas Day over brunch the conversation drifted to past trips. I mentioned I was so worried about the election in 2018 that I left the country on election day to travel solo in Germany for three weeks. I wanted to understand what happened. One of my friends answered with the simple explanation people were afraid. 

It’s way more complicated. 

I wonder how the Republican Party of today will really look in a historical review with a cult of personality at the center, grievance politics, othering, book banning, retribution, revenge, and an embrace of authoritarianism. 

I closed out my week to see for myself the shipping containers surrounding Peoples Park. I’ve never been deeply involved in People’s Park, but as I think about it and look at it, it strikes me as small-minded leaders carrying grudges from one generation of chancellors to the next and developers determined to turn the debacle into a gentrifying opportunity, a process that already has a big head start. The park was destroyed months ago with clear cutting nearly all the trees. There were other places to build.h

I am writing to express deep concern about the recent civil lawsuit filed by hundreds of Yazidi-Americans against Lafarge S.A., the French conglomerate. The lawsuit alleges Lafarge's involvement in providing material support to the Islamic State, which led to grave consequences for the Yazidi population. Lafarge's admission of guilt in a criminal conspiracy to support ISIS and another terrorist group, the Al-Nusra Front, is distressing. The company, along with Lafarge Cement Syria, knowingly engaged in activities supporting armed groups in Syria from August 2013 to November 2014. 

What makes this lawsuit even more poignant is that it was brought forth by Nobel Prize winner Nadia Murad and over 400 Yazidi survivors – all American citizens – who endured a harrowing "campaign of genocide" perpetrated by ISIS. This included horrifying acts such as mass executions, abductions, torture, sexual violence, the use of child soldiers, and the destruction of the Yazidi homeland. 

Ms. Murad's statement reflecting on her own ordeal underlines the gravity of the situation. Her words, "Unfortunately, my story is not unique among Yazidis. It is the reality of thousands of Yazidi women. Even more tragic is that our horror took place under the awareness of and thanks to the support of powerful corporations like Lafarge," should serve as a stark reminder of the complicity of entities in enabling such atrocities. 

The implications of corporate entities supporting terrorism, directly or indirectly, cannot be understated. It's crucial for justice to prevail, not only for the victims but also to ensure accountability and prevent such collaboration in the future.

Blinken Slips, Admits Why Wars Are a "Win-win"

Looking for a favorable argument to keep selling US weapons to sustain wars in Ukraine and Israel, Secretary of State Antony Blinken explained: “If you look at the investments that we’ve made in Ukraine’s defense to deal with this aggression, 90% of the security assistance we’ve provided has actually been spent here in the United States with our manufacturers, with our production, and that’s produced more American jobs, more growth in our own economy. So, this has also been a win-win that we need to continue.”

But as former Army Colonel and U.S. State Department official Ann Wright pointed out in a damning critique delivered in a speech before the UN Security Council: "The win-win is for the military industrial complex and the politicians and retired government officials who are offered senior positions in companies immediately after their retirements! And it’s certainly not a win-win for the innocent civilians who are killed in these conflicts." (PS: Wright resigned her post in protest of Washington's illegal Iraq war)

Pope Is No Dope

Pope Francis has long spoken out about the horrors and immorality of war but his Christmas day message from the balcony of the Vatican took his concerns a bit further. The Pope dared to illuminate the root of the War Problem and he dared to speak its name: "The global weapons industry."

The Chronicle chose to run this revelation under a headline that read: "Pope Blasts Weapons Industry." The headline reveals another consequence of "social militarism"—i.e., the weaponization of language. The Chron could have said the pope "deplores," "denounces," or even "curses" the arms industry. Instead, they opted for a word that is wedded to the word "bomb."

As the US Federal Budget makes clear (more than 40% of our tax-dollars go to "defense"): If we want to stop hunger, poverty, and homelessness, let's just stop paying for war. 

Fashion Plates
ROCK VOX
BEL SOLAR
TTYLLS (?)
KTNINPT (Kitten Input?)
LVNGMY (Loving My Car?
XZQVW (ExecueVW? On a VW Golf)
CORRETO (Fan of the Amazon download?)
TAJGLAM (On Taj's glamorous pink jeep complete with artsy wheel-spokes) 

Bumper Snickers 

Honk If You're Horny
Death Eater Punks F---- Off!
Magical Non-linear Thinking for President
Honk! If You Have a Bee in Your Bonnet 

When the Chips are Down 

I recently picked up a bag of Good Health Natural Products' Veggie Chips—self-advertized as a "Positively Snackable TM" potato-based treat sporting a "NonGMO project" label. Good Health is a company that proclaims its goal is "living life to the fullest, aka having a great 'Lifeitude' ®." 

Unfortunately, the small print on the bottom of the flip side of their bag of snacks contains a small notice that says: "WARNING: Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including acrylamide, which are known to the State of California to cause cancer. For more information go to: www.P85Warnings.ca,gov/food" I left the bag on the shelf in order to protect my Lifeitude. 

The Work and the Wonks Behind the Woke  

Just released on YouTube: "Unschooled: 'The PragerU Curriculum' from Meet the Press Reports." The mini-doc answers the conundrum: "How did one man go from right-wing talk show host to the head of a popular online education program? 

PragerU rejects "woke" education that forces children to discuss "gender pronouns" and critical race theory. Sure, white people enslaved Africans, these self-serving scholars argue, but here's an "overlooked fact." As they proudly point out: "It was white people who ended slavery." 

This and other stunning conservative revelations can be found in this new 33-minute special report. 

Weird Words and Odd Phrases 1
Is it a long-standing example of institutionalized "greenwashing" that has encouraged corporate critics to refer massive, polluting factories as nothing more than "plants"? 

Weird Words and Odd Phrases 2
One of the Christmas season's favorite carols is "The First Noel." The lyrics contain a puzzling line that salutes the birth of Jesus and announces "Born is the King of Israel." 

According to biblical historians, Israel’s Old Testament origins "can be traced back to Abraham, who is considered the father of both Judaism (through his son Isaac) and Islam (through his son Ishmael)." So shouldn't both Jewish and Muslim residents of Israel have shared title to the territory? And what's the story behind Jesus becoming the "King of Israel"? What was Nathanial thinking when he said to Jesus (John 1:49): “Rabbi, you are the Son of God! You are the King of Israel!” 

If that was the expectation—that the Messiah would free the citizens of Israel—why did all-knowing Jehovah allow Judas Iscariot to entrap the Son of God thereby setting up his "only begotten son" to fall victim to a vicious government instead of surviving to become a liberating ruler of His people? 

Billionaires Should "Feel the Bern"
Berkeley rabble-raiser Robert Reich recently posted a stunning stat on his Inequality Media website that proclaimed 1 percent of America's wealthiest citizens now own 40 percent of the nation's wealth. 

Meanwhile, US rebel Senator Bernie Sanders (and chair of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions) has stepped forth with an even more stunning estimate of the country's growing Wealth Gap. 

In a fund-raising letter for the Coalition for Human Needs, Sanders stated: "In America today the very rich are becoming much, much richer—they've never had it so good. We now have the absurd situation in which two multi-billionaires own more wealth than the bottom 40% of Americans, the top 1% own more wealth than the bottom 92% and the gap between rich and poor is wider than at any time in the last 100 years." 

Reich cites further research by UC Berkeley's Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman of the London School of Economics, that revealed "the richest one-hundredth of one percent of Americans now hold over 11 percent of the nation’s total wealth. That’s a higher share than the top .01 percent held in 1929, before the Great Crash." 

Putting that revelation in more personal terms, Reich reveals: "We’re talking about 16,000 people, each worth at least $110 million." 

The Other 9/11/ 

As we all know, Salvador Allende was a Chilean physician and the first democratic socialist president elected in 1970. What we didn't know at the time was that the CIA, Richard Nixon, and Henry Kissinger were behind the coup plot that toppled Chile's elected socialist government. Thousands were tortured and thousands were disappeared. The US Twin Tower and Pentagon attacks on September 11 killed around 3,000 Americans. Chile's 9/11 killed more civilians than the US 9/11. 

Here's a link to a song by Dean Reed, a US-born rock idol who became radicalized after traveling abroad and seeing the results of Washington's imperial meddling. Reed (who once topped Elvis Presley on the US song charts) went on to give concerts around the world and become deeply involved in the Chilean struggle for freedom. 

During his years living in East Germany, Reed stared in many movies, including El Cantor, in which he assumed the role of Chilean singer-activist Victor Jarra, who was tortured and killed by the US-backed junta. 

Once known as "the most famous American in the world," Reed was blacklisted in the US and was assassinated shortly before he planned to return to his Colorado home and run for Gary Hart's seat in the US Senate. 

Dean Reed may have been an unsung hero in the US but he was a voice of hope for the world's most desperate and deprived people. 

Dean Reed may have been an unsung hero in the US but he was a voice of hope for the world's most desperate and deprived people. 

 

It should be obvious to every responsible journalist that anything the Loser of the 2020 election says ought to be fact checked. The number of Trump's documented lies while President exceeds 30,000. By printing the AP story ("Trump claims Ignorance about Hitler comparisons") without doubting Trump's word, the editors lend credence to his claim of ignorance. 

While Trump is undoubtedly ignorant about many things a President ought to know, Hitler's speeches would not be on that list. Vanity Fair magazine reported in September 1990 that ex-wife Ivana Trump told her lawyer that Donald "reads a book of Hitler's collected speeches, 'My New Order,' which he keeps in a cabinet by his bed." 

Trump certainly knows he lifted Hitler's vile language into his recent campaign speeches. He was following the example of a master propagandist and genocidal ogre.  

Editors who republish AP stories, need to fact check that source as well.

The recent reports from Gaza paint a harrowing picture of ongoing devastation. According to Gaza health officials, over 21,500 Palestinians have lost their lives in the past 12 weeks due to Israeli assaults, with civilians targeted, including an attack on the Maghazi refugee camp during Christmas. 

Husam Zomlot, head of the Palestinian Mission to the United Kingdom, has characterized these actions as an "on-air genocide," urging attention to the wider implications beyond Palestinian oppression. Prime Minister Rishi Sunak's acknowledgment of excessive civilian deaths underscores the urgent need for a sustainable ceasefire. 

The admission by Israeli military officials regarding the deadly strikes, alongside UNRWA's plea for a ceasefire due to catastrophic hunger in Gaza, demands immediate global attention and action. 

The suppression of dissent and disregard for international order in this conflicth have ramifications that stretch far beyond the region, impacting fundamental democratic rights worldwide.

Literary fiction is distinguished from genre fiction by the emphasis on meaning over entertainment. Usually, literary fiction is character driven rather than plot driven. 

Four of 2023’s best literary fiction novels are categorized as mystery, thriller, and suspense. 

A World of Curiosities, Louise Penny 

In the 18th Inspector Armand Gamache novel, Louise Penny provides a plotline where one mystery segues into another. “A World of Curiosities” begins with a flashback, where Inspector Gamache investigated the death of a female drug addict and uncovered horrendous child abuse and pornography. A decade later, the addict’s damaged children reappear in Three Pines, where Gamache lives. In a seemingly unrelated incident, the residents discover a hidden room containing a copy of a 17th century symbolic painting. When Gamache studies the mammoth artwork, he realizes that it contains messages directed to him by the infamous serial killer, John Fleming. 

“A World of Curiosities” affords Louise Penny the opportunity to reflect on good and evil how brave men and women move forward in tragic circumstances. Armand Gamache is a troubled hero, struggling to rise to the challenge of being the only person capable of stopping a brilliant killer. 

Holly: Stephen King 

Diminutive private investigator, Holly Gibney, is operating Finders Keepers detective agency by herself when she gets a request to find a missing girl, Bonnie Dahl. Because of the coronavirus epidemic, the mythical town of Brighton, Ohio, is shut down. Nonetheless, Holly is relentless and soon understands that a serial killer is snatching victims off the Brighton streets. 

The thriller is an opportunity for Stephen King to elaborate the character of Holly Gibney. She hasn’t always been treated fairly, but she has persevered. 

Past Lying: Val McDermid 

Because of Covid, Scotland’s Historic Cases Police Unit is quiescent. DCI Karen Pirie and her colleague, Daisy Mortimer, are holed up in Pirie’s boyfriend’s spacious Edinburgh flat. A friend, a librarian from the National Archives, tells them of a strange new acquisition: the last manuscript of a recently deceased mystery writer, “The Vanishing of Laurel Oliver.” The librarian believes the manuscript plot bears a striking resemblance to the unsolved disappearance of a college student, Lara Hardie. Karen Pirie agrees, and her team begins to look deeper into the Hardie case and Lara’s connection to the dead writer, Jake Stein. 

The long mystery is kept entertaining by the quality of McDermid’s writing, particularly the characterizations of Pirie and her team. McDermid provides extended consideration of relationships. 

Small Mercies: Dennis Lehance 

In 1974, a time of Boston racial tension, a black man, Auggie Williamson, is killed and a white teenager, Jules Fennessy, disappears. Her mother, Mary Pat, sets out to find what happened to Jules and runs afoul of the Irish mob. 

Dennis Lehane’s characterization of Mary Pat Fennessy is spot on, as is his description of her hard-scrabble Irish Boston neighborhood 

Summary 

Not every page of these mystery/thrillers is devoted to action; there are moments where the author, speaking through the characters, explores larger themes. 

In A World of Curiosities Louise Penny asks: “how do we remain hopeful when there is evil all around us?” Inspector Gamache carries the weight of moral responsibility and struggles with depression, “How can I go on when the forces of evil are so powerful?” Of the four authors, Louise Penny is the only one to directly deal with this topic, but it surfaces in each novel. 

The common theme that links the four novels is misogyny: men mistreating women. While Inspector Gamache is the only male protagonist, there is opportunity in A World of Curiosities for Louise Penny to discuss situations where women are discriminated against. In Holly misogyny is the dominant theme. In Past Lying there are multiple allusions to sexism and chauvinism. For example, Karen Pirie decides to break up with her boyfriend, Hamish Mckenzie because he’s too full of himself and decides the covid lockdown rules don’t apply to him. Finally, inSmall Mercies, Mary Pat Fennessy lives in traditional Irish culture where women are seen but not heard; searching for her missing daughter, one of the problems she encounters is that none of the men take her seriously. 

In literary fiction, there’s often a connection between the contemporary cultural zeitgeist and the narrative. In 2023, it’s not surprising that the dominant themes of these four mystery/thrillers are “the battle between good and evil” and “misogyny.” 

Happy New year!

Benny Gantz, de facto leader of Israel’s opposition, has now been handed exactly what he needs to topple Benjamin Netanyahu’s extreme right-wing coalition. In addition to all the vehement critiicism of Netanyahu from the families of Israeli hostages held in Gaza, there is now the episode, humiliating for Israel, that IDF forces mistook three Israeli hostages in Gaza City for terrorists and killed them on Friday, December 15. 

The three men killed were carrying a white flag on a stick, and calling for help in Hebrew; but it is not clear whether they were released by Hamas or had somehow escaped their captors when they were mistakenly killed by Israeli soldiers. Further, Netanyahu’s war on Gaza is not going very well right now. On Wednesday, December 13, the Israeli government acknowledged that Hamas militants successfully ambushed IDF soldiers in Gaza City, killing at least nine of them. Further, On Sunday, December 24, the Israeli government announced that fourteen IDF soldiers had been killed in Gaza over the last two days. 

I have long held that if Benny Gantz wishes to bring down Netanyahu’s extreme right-wing coalition, he should focus on Netanyahu’s failure to prioritise obtaining release of the hostages. Now, it is clear that Netanyahu’s insistent prosecution of the war endangers the safety and chances for survival of the hostages. 

Israel’s relentless indiscriminate bombing throughout Gaza has already killed at least three hostages, and now three more have been killed by IDF gunfire. At the onset of Israel’s response to the attack by Hamas on October 7. Benny Gantz joined Netanyahu’s three-man War Cabinet, comprised of the Prime Minister, Benny Gantz, and Minister of Defence Yoau Gallent. Gantz did so saying on October 8, that “There is a time for peace and a time for war. This a time for war,” This makes it difficult for Benny Gantz to now withdraw his support for Netanyahu’s war on Gaza without it seeming to be a personally motivated power grab. However, if Gantz now says that a time for peace has come, at the very least a peace allowing negotiations for hostage relief, he will gain much popular support.  

By withdrawing his National Unity Party from Netanyahu’s extreme right-wing coalition, Benny Gantz can topple Netanyahu. Then, as de facto leader of the opposition Gantz may be asked by Israel’s President Isaac Herzog to form a new governing coalition. If Gantz does so, his first priority should be an effort to obtain release of all the hostages held in Gaza even if the price involves Israel’s release of thousands of Palestinians held in Israeli prisons, including Marwan Barghouti. 

Should he succeed in this hostage release endeavour, that will be an enormous accomplishment and will win Gantz overwhelming support in Israel. Perhaps it might even give Gantz a mandate to begin exploratory discussions with Marwan Barghouti over a possible two-state solution. However, if Gantz misses this moment, Netanyahu will no doubt scfuttle any negotiations in Cairo over possible hostage release with Hamas political leader Ismail Haniyeh Instead, Netanyahu will icontinue his all-out assault on Gaza. Despite calls for a ceasefire from many prominent Israeli politicians, including former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who also calls for Netanyahu to resign — something Netanyahu will surely never do; Netanyahu seems fully entrenched in pursuing his genocidal war on Palestinians in Gaza. If Benny Gantz refuses to rise to the moment and topple Netanyahu now, that will no doubt mark the end of any hope that Benny Gantz can be a viable alternative to Netanyahu. It’s that simple. As I see it, it’s now or never for Benny Gantz. Topple Netanyahu now or you’re done.

The sea is bigger than any man or woman is. A human being can't beat up the waves, can't overpower them, or (in many cases) can't outsmart them either. Surfers and swimmers, some of them experienced, probably have respect for the waves.

When I was younger and had physical competence, I could still barely manage a swim in a swimming pool and would never dare venture very far into the water at a beach. That's just because I'm usually aware of my limitations.

When my mind and body were taken by psychosis, the feeling of it resembled being at the beach, going too far into the waters, and being swept out to sea, at the mercy of a massively overpowering undertow.

This is the power of psychosis. You may believe your mind is strong. You may believe your will is strong. Psychosis--that is strong. If you are subject to psychosis, you need help.

Practitioners of Zen Buddhism seem to believe themselves superior to normal human folly. This is not accurate. A reason to feel superior and a feeling of being a "master" as a higher status, that's where Zen seems farcical. I practice mindfulness, but it doesn't make me superior. Human error is inescapable and practicing meditation and/or yoga don't cure schizophrenia. 

When you are subject to psychosis and have aspirations of Buddhist attainment, you had better be careful. Buddhism attracts many people with mental differences, and many who find it hard to manage their emotions. Buddhism attracts a lot of mentally disabled people. Many of us have sought some better path than being medicated, being restricted, and being disabled. 

Zen doesn't bring immunity to the conditions of life. It doesn't cure a substance abuse problem. It doesn't cure a psychiatric condition. It won't make you immune to disability following a stroke. It won't make you immortal. Zen, however, is mostly not farcical. It does attract the worried well who find it hard to like themselves. When they believe they are attained, it symbolizes an accomplishment, one that makes them better, superior, compared to others. 

I studied under two different men who never acted superior. They connected to me as equals. I didn't realize it at the time, but they were my teachers. They never advised going off medication. They were not immune to the effects of aging or of any other of the myriad of human conditions that make people flawed and suffering. 

Schizophrenia is a very rough disease to have. When psychiatric practitioners saw me doing well, they decided to change the diagnosis. This is hypocrisy as opposed to Hippocrates. It is where doctors rule out a person's individual efforts to get well, and where they rule out that a person with schizophrenia could accomplish anything significant. 

But if you are sick, you need medicine. Why suffer when you don't have to? The extreme force of relapsing into psychosis is nothing to play games with. You can't get rid of schizophrenia with mindfulness. You can make life better, but still live with the disease, through mindfulness. You can ease a portion of the symptoms. But medication is needed, and meditation doesn't repair a brain defect. The point is, there are many parts to the brain. And it doesn't matter how good your brain is or isn't. What matters is how well you use it. 

---

Jack Bragen lives and writes in Martinez, California.

Worth Noting:

The Agenda & Rules Policy Committee is expected to meet on Thursday, January 4 at 2:30 pm.

The draft agenda for the January 16, 2024 City Council meeting is not available as no meeting agenda is posted. City Council is on winter recess through January 15, 2024.

Check the City website after 5 pm Tuesday, January 2, 2024 https://berkeleyca.gov/

Or go directly to the Agenda & Rules Policy Committee webpage for the draft agenda after 5 pm Tuesday. https://berkeleyca.gov/your-government/city-council/council-committees/policy-committee-agenda-rules

The Landmarks Preservation Committee meeting for Thursday evening January 4 has been cancelled.