Reviewed by James Roy MacBean
Sunday October 24, 2021 - 07:56:00 PM
At San Francisco Opera, American director Matthew Ozawa sets Beethoven’s Fidelio in a modern detention facility with steel cages and elaborate surveillance equipment. The result, alas, is the most ridiculous fairy tale version of Fidelio one could imagine. Critics have long noted the wish-fulfilment fantasy element in Beethoven’s only opera, which portrays the unjust imprisonment of a political dissident, Florestan, who is miraculously rescued at the very moment he is about to be murdered by a corrupt tyrant, his rescue owing in part to the actions of his wife but also, and primarily, to the fortuitous last minute arrival of a benign government leader, who in this fairy tale production, not only saves the life of Florestan and arrests his would-be murderer but also frees all the detention facility’s prisoners. Wow! Could there ever be a more politically correct and totally unbelievable pipe dream version of Fidelio than this?
-more-