Full Text

 

News

Updated: Two Dead, One Injured in Collision on Marin Avenue

Bay City News
Tuesday May 11, 2021 - 06:17:00 PM

Two people are dead following a collision between two cars early Tuesday afternoon in Berkeley, police said. 

Officers responded at 1:39 p.m. to Marin Avenue near Spruce Street and found the cars on Marin Avenue between Spruce Street and San Benito Avenue. 

A woman passenger in one of the cars was pronounced dead at the scene and the driver of that car, a man, was taken to a hospital where he died, according to police. 

The driver of the other car suffered moderate injuries and was taken to a hospital.  

One of the vehicles hit a tree as a result of the collision, police spokesman Officer Byron White said.  

Both cars were traveling downhill on Marin Avenue when they collided, White said.  

"We know this was a high-force collision," he said.  

The cars were a block from each other when they finally came to rest, White said. The cause has yet to be determined. A utility pole was damaged in the collision, police said and power to some in the area may be out. Anyone with information about the collision is asked to call Berkeley police at (510) 981-5900.


Press Release: Fatal Accident Investigation on Marin Avenue

Berkeley Police Department
Tuesday May 11, 2021 - 05:08:00 PM

At 1:39 pm, emergency personnel responded to the area of Marin Avenue and Spruce Street on a report of a collision. On Marin Avenue between Spruce Street and San Benito Street, emergency personnel found two vehicles that had been involved in a collision. In one of the vehicles (a 4-door sedan), a female passenger was pronounced deceased at the scene and the driver was transported to a local hospital where he later died. In the second vehicle (also a passenger car), a female driver received moderate injuries from the collision and was transported to the hospital. 

Due to the severity of the collision, the Department’s Fatal Accident Investigation Team is handling the investigation and will remain at the scene for the next few hours. 

In addition to the collision, a power pole was damaged at the scene. PG&E determined the repair will likely affect approximately 1,000 people in the area for the next several hours. 

If you have any information about this collision, please contact the Berkeley Police Department at (510) 981-5900.


Response Re "RoadMap Home" Comment

Councilmember Kate Harrison
Tuesday May 11, 2021 - 12:03:00 PM

Even with the 1.5 million homes that the Embarcadero Center indicates are needed in California (much fewer than McKenzie’s estimated 3.5 million), it is clear we need to increase our efforts to build housing. I agree with [the author] that just building more housing is not the solution – our focus needs to be on Affordable Housing accompanied with protections for tenants and small homeowners and policies that discourage speculation. As I have stated publicly, I am against wanton upzoning and don’t believe it will yield affordability for the average person. RoadMap Home avoids the very simplistic idea.

[The author] characterized the RoadMap Home report as a “project” and I’m not sure what [they're] getting at by using that word. The Roadmap isn’t an actual housing development nor is it a legislative package ready for a vote. It’s a demonstration of how complete our response to housing issues must be. I may not love every aspect of this plan but it is refreshing to see its wide scope and its focus on state support for local governments. This is the attitude that has been conspicuously missing from this discussion to date. 

RoadMap does endorse reducing two major roadblocks to the construction of Affordable Housing -- state funding and barriers for approval of affordable housing. In fact, there are many parts of the RoadMap that reinforce what Affordable Housing advocates have been saying for a long time: the state needs to do more to support local governments in their creation of affordable housing. Recommendation C6 calls for “reimbursing local government 50% of fee waivers or reductions for affordable housing” which would provide Berkeley with much-needed funds to create the affordable housing we need, not for speeding development. Federal funding has stagnated or fallen over the years, and Governor Brown’s dissolution of the Redevelopment Agencies have left many cities without the funding to make significant investments in affordability. In section A, the RoadMap advocates for providing local governments with flexible ongoing funding for a range of homelessness solutions (A1), empowering voters to support building affordable homes locally by setting the threshold for passage of housing ballot measures at 55% (A6), and initiating a $10 Billion state-wide housing bond (A3). In section B it calls for increased taxes on the wealthy (B2), closing tax loopholes (B3) and a reform of Proposition 13 (B4). Section D encourages the state to adopt many of our local tenant protections at a state level (D1), repeal or reform Costa-Hawkins (D2), and create new protections against housing discrimination (D4). These are all incredible boons to Berkeley and a reinforcement of actions this city already supports. 

Policy recommendations C1 and C3 both reduce barriers to building more Affordable Housing. C3 advocates for this, with a specific call out for exempting hotel conversions under Project Homekey, which would be a significant benefit to Berkeley. CEQA has ostensibly been about environmental concerns but the environmental answer is not to stop housing locally just to create more commuters. None of this can happen without strong objective design standards for Berkeley. This will be increasingly important under the new RHNA cycle and will help address many environmental and aesthetic concerns in new construction. 

RoadMap Home is endorsed by local housing advocates, including the East Bay Housing Organizations. It is a comprehensive package full of many ideas -- including some great ones.


Q & A with Councilmember Kate Harrison on Berkeley’s Complex Housing Crisis

Negeene Mosaed and Elana Auerbach
Saturday May 08, 2021 - 12:14:00 PM

Negeene and Elana sat down with Councilmember Kate Harrison (District 4) to get a better understanding of the complex housing situation in our city. This is part one of a two part series.

Q1: How was the determination made that Berkeley must produce 9,000 more housing units, 60% at market rate and 40% below market rate by 2031?

A1: Cities do not have exclusive control over housing policy.

State Housing and Community Development (HCD) sets how many new units the Bay Area should develop. HCD is saying that 441,000 new housing units need to be permitted in the region in eight years. The Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) is charged with allocating those between cities in what’s known as the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA).

The real driver is HCD’s questionable 2030 population assumptions — the Bay Area will grow from 7.2 to 9.2 million people in nine years. By 2031, San Francisco is expected to grow from 883,000 to 1.45 million and Berkeley from 120,000 to 141,000. Is that feasible or even desirable? I don’t think so. 

HCD’s 2020 population projections exceed the recently released 2020 Census, yet their 2030 estimate relies on that 2020 projection. These estimates predate COVID and do not reflect trends in outmigration, working from home, and the lessened need (or desire) to live in the inner core. 

How ABAG distributes those numbers has also changed. It assumes a slight increase in Berkeley’s share (from 1.5% to 1.7%) of Bay Area units. In contrast to the last RHNA cycle, existing density and local building costs play less of a role. Berkeley’s high density and high construction costs are not adequately considered. Instead, criteria such as being in a “high opportunity zone” or near a University are emphasized. 

Also, RHNA focuses only on traditional housing units and doesn’t account for Berkeley’s alternative housing models, for example many Group Living Accommodations, where several bedrooms share a kitchen, or U.C.’s dormitories. This is particularly imbalanced, since much of our population increase is University related. Thousands of existing unpermitted units are also uncounted. We also get no credit for exceeding the numbers in the last eight years. 

We are asked to build more without credit for all that we have and are building. 

These factors lead to a determination that, by 2031, Berkeley should permit 9,000 more units, an almost 20% increase over Berkeley’s existing 51,000 units. This is a 200% increase over the numbers we were expected to meet — and met — in the last eight years. 

What’s behind these high expectations? The flawed methodology discussed above plays a part. For some, there is a sincere belief that by just pushing harder we can accommodate huge growth quickly. This does not account for how growth should be funded (the burden will be on local government), the proportion of affordable housing or the impacts on the local environment. 

But I also believe that, in some quarters, these numbers are set artificially high, knowing cities will fail. Senator Weiner’s SB 35 requires all units in cities that don’t meet their overall target for permitting housing to be approved by staff without an opportunity for community input. This would happen even if the city approved adequate housing that developers never completed. 

SB35 mirrors the misperception that local discretion is the biggest impediment to housing, not broader economic trends. Berkeley’s housing pipeline report shows that the average project spans 63 months from start to finish, only five of which are at the Zoning Adjustment Board and/or City Council, if appealed. Most of the 63 months is developers acquiring building permits and actually building. (I want to thank our Planning Department for working to make our permit process more efficient). In addition, many projects don’t get underway even when they have been approved but cities are held responsible under SB 35 for the number of fully permitted projects, even if we don’t control that. 

The demand that we forfeit local discretion also relies on the myth that housing appeals are common. Very few projects are appealed, and most of these appeals are rejected by the Council. The uncommon appeal that the Council approves would have had real impacts on the fabric of our city. I am happy that our Council retained discretion in its recent upzoning legislation but Weiner’s SB 35 will override that. 

Even with projects currently underway for teachers and at BART stations and local churches and others, aided by generous Berkeley taxpayers supporting Measure O in 2018, more and more people are left behind as land prices and median incomes increase in the Bay Area. Between 2015 and 2019, Berkeley met only 11% of our housing targets for low-income housing and none for moderate. Innovations like the Carpenters’ Union manufactured housing facility on Mare Island will help bring down the cost of construction. But increasing land competition makes it harder for affordable housing developers or tenants to purchase properties; displacement pressures are driving out residents faster than we can build replacement housing. High RHNA targets of mostly market-rate housing don’t change these material realities. 

What happens when those homes aren’t built? More people become homeless or displaced, live in overcrowded conditions or move away, driving incredible distances to work here. Their lives will be immeasurably harder, communities will be disrupted, and everyone’s transportation problems will get worse. Imbalanced housing combined with State failures to fund transportation hurt people, the planet and disrupt our labor market. 

Q2: Is San Francisco challenging their RHNA numbers? 

A2: I believe San Francisco is challenging the distribution of the Bay Area’s numbers and whether more units should be allocated to the Peninsula closer to jobs. If we look at where people have not built housing, let’s be frank — it’s not here; we have exceeded past targets. It’s not Oakland. It’s not San Francisco. So why are such a large number of units being required here and we’re not getting credit for what we already have? I am looking forward to Berkeley joining in asking these questions. 

to be continued… 


This was first published in the Berkeley Times on May 6, 2021. Reimagining Berkeley is co-edited by Negeene Mosaed and Elana Auerbach, two longtime residents who invite the community to envision an equitable Berkeley where everyone thrives. Please share your dreams and visions of Berkeley could be at reimaginingberkeley@gmail.com. 

v; 

v


Ralph Raymond Walbridge II
1928 - 2021

Jane Welford
Monday May 10, 2021 - 09:30:00 PM

Ralph Raymond Walbridge, son of Ralph and Myra Knupp Walbridge, died at his residence in Berkeley, California, on March 26. He was 92.

Ralph was born on August 18, 1928, in Santa Barbara, California. He graduated from South Pasadena-San Marino High School. In 1961, he received his Bachelor's Degree from San Francisco State College, where he majored in Language Arts.

Ralph's work experiences were diverse. He was a writer and editor for Lockheed and other engineering companies; He was a social worker in San Francisco for eight years, where he also wrote articles and poems for the agency newsletter. In New Mexico, he built adobe homes and fought fires across the West as a member of Southwest Firefighters. Ralph also participated in many poetry readings at local venues with other poets. 

Always, Ralph was a poet, an eternal maker of verses. We are fortunate to be left with an abundance of his work. His poetry reflected his great intelligence and ability to go further, deeper. The desire for his writings to be in accord with Truth also applied to his interactions with everyone he encountered. He was much respected for his wise counsel and ability to see beyond the literal. 

Ralph was a beautiful, gentle presence, always exploring untrod paths, seeking understanding. He often found inspiration from his love of nature and the many trails he walked with family and friends 

Ralph is lovingly remembered by his sons: Charles, Julian, and Aland; four grandchildren; and dedicated friends Jane Welford, Emily Hancock, Carol Chandlee, and Leatrice Asher. 

A celebration of Ralph's life will be held at Redwood Gardens Community Room, Berkeley, California. Please contact Jane Welford (510) 812-7450 for the date and time. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

Rubies 

snow rides the rafters 

as day comes down 

a shute of sun 

 

truth burns wearily 

in the fireplace 

 

an old man rises pensively 

seeking bearings in pinon 

and sage 

 

landmarks for the definitive mind 

 

he frets sometimes 

a joker pulled from 

a random deck of memories 

 

the wild one played in too many hands 

 

he falls back 

exhausted 

refers to the cold outside 

 

what can be saved along the red deck of sun 

shadows will find 

lengths of ground throughout 

the day 

between them he will tarry 

 

snow will darken 

in places where its fallen 

—RRW 

 

 


 


Opinion

Public Comment

Kate Harrison’s Premature Request for the Berkeley City Council to Endorse "Roadmap Home 2030"

Zelda Bronstein
Sunday May 09, 2021 - 07:32:00 PM

Item 23 on the Berkeley council’s May 11 agenda is a request from Councilmember Kate Harrison that the council endorse Roadmap Home 2030 and send state legislators a letter urging them to adopt the recommendations of the plan.

For reasons detailed below, Harrison should pull the item, wait until the community has vetted Roadmap Home 2030 in its entirety, and then decide whether she still wants to seek the council’s endorsement of the project. 

Launched in March 2021 with $1 million from the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative and unspecified amounts from the James Irvine Foundation and the Conrad Hilton Foundation, Roadmap Home 2030 is led by the California Housing Partnership, Housing California, and the California Budget & Policy Center. It advances 57 “solutions” that, it claims, “address the root causes of housing insecurity and homelessness across the state.” 

Harrison’s item calls the Roadmap “an example of a rigorous approach that acknowledges athe complexity of the housing crisis and provides many actionable policies that when employed together, can substantially improve the state of housing in Berkeley and the state of California in the next ten years.” 

Unfortunately, some of those “actionable” policies will not solve but rather worsen California’s housing woes. For example: 

  • “End exclusionary and racially discriminatory zoning in resource-rich neighborhoods by allowing increases in building height and density for mixed-income and affordable housing developments.” (RM C1). Sounds a lot like Toni Atkins’ upzoning bill, SB 9.
  • A CEQA exemption for projects that are 100% affordable to low-income households (RM C3). So people of modest means don’t need to live in environmentally protected places?
  • Tying "Housing Element compliance and revamped Prohousing incentives to state transportation funding resources” (RM E5). This is part of Newsom’s push to preempt local land use discretion in behalf of the tech/real estate industry.
 

Two of these proposals, RM C1 (upzoning) and RM C3 (CEQA exemption), are among the measures that the Roadmap Home group has designated as its top twelve priorities. 

Harrison’s Item 23 specifically mentions just one of the proposals listed above: the Roadmap’s upzoning proposal, stating: “The Berkeley City Council has already taken action on some of the items identified in the Roadmap Homes 2030 report. For example, the recent resolution on ending exclusionary zoning is recommendation C1 in Roadmap Home 2030.” 

The council’s approval of that resolution is deeply controversial in Berkeley. Harrison couldn’t vote on it, because family commitments prevented her from attending the meeting. The implication here is that had she attended, she would have voted to approve. 

Her selective presentation of the Roadmap agenda is regrettable, especially in an item on the consent agenda about a complex project that I’m sure few people in Berkeley have even heard of. 

Roadmap Home 2030 needs to be thoroughly vetted—a process that cannot occur at a council meeting but only in the press and in community gatherings. Only after such a vetting occurs would it be appropriate to have the council deliberate on whether to endorse the project. 

I ask, then, that Harrison pull Item 23 from the council’s May 11 agenda. If she wants to pursue its endorsement, she should tell the community at large why in an opinion piece posted in the Planet or Berkeleyside; see what kind of response she gets; and then decide whether she still wants to put Roadmap Home 2030 before the council. That would be the path of democratic accountability. 


Indian PM Modi the “sup-spreader”

Jagjit Singh
Monday May 10, 2021 - 09:34:00 PM

India is seething with an anger and utter despair. Family relatives are watching helplessly as their love ones slip away gasping for breath, their lungs infected with the deadly coronavirus. Oblivious of the suffering, Prime Minister, Narendra Modi put his political fortunes ahead of the welfare of the Indian people. Much like Donald Trump, Modi surrounds himself with sycophants who continue to nourish his ego. 

The ruling BJP party elite stated in early February – “it can be said with pride that India defeated COVID-19 under the able, sensible, committed and visionary leadership of Prime Minister Modi. The party unequivocally hails its leadership for introducing India to the world as a proud and victorious nation in the fight against COVID.” What utter nonsense! BJP chief minister in Uttarakhand state said: “I invite all devotees across the world to come to Haridwar, take a holy dip in the Ganga. Nobody will be stopped in the name of COVID-19, as we assure the faith in God will overcome the fear of the virus.” How irresponsible and cruel, perpetuating a false belief that dipping in the most polluted river in the world will magically wash away all their sins. 

The national vice-president of the Indian Medical Association (IMA), Dr Navjot Dahiya has called Prime Minister Narendra Modi a ‘super spreader’ and blamed for the second wave of COVID-19. The scarcity of medical oxygen has become a major reason for the death of so many patients in every part of the country. Inexplicably, several projects for installing oxygen manufacturing plants are still pending clearance with the Union government with bodies piling up in crematoriums and long queues of ambulances outside hospitals in almost every city of the country. The Chief Justice of Madras accused the Election Commission and the BJP government of wholesale murder. 

Responding to the acute shortage of oxygen, Sikh temples have installed makeshift oxygen supply units which deliver oxygen which they are offering without charge to the general public. Hindu temples could support this effort by purchasing critical needed equipment from their large gold reserves. Ignoring demands to suspend elections, Modi reveled in the huge crowds mistaking crowd size as testament to approval of his policies. In spite of wielding power and influence, his party the BJP suffered a humiliating defeat in the West Bengal elections. Government’s censors following the Trump playbook, demanded Twitter remove tweets critical of Modi’s leadership. Modi supporters poured vitriol on honest reporters, who were threatened with confiscation of their property and denounced as unpatriotic. Better to perpetuate a lie than voice the truth? Sounds familiar? 

In a country dominated by male leasers, the only female chief minister, Mamata Banerjee, won a decisive victory to defeat Modi’s divisive, misogynist politics. There is mounting opposition to Modi’s centralizing, authoritarian juggernaut, which seeks to destroy India’s historical federalism and its secular roots and transform India into an autocratic Hindu state. A prominent Indian scientist, predicated an even more devastating third wave pf the virus. Meanwhile Western countries are hording large quantities of vaccines. There is a crucial need to lift the patent protections and allow third world countries to manufacture their own vaccines. Profits should NEVER triumph concerns for human life. NOBODY will be safe until the whole world is safe.


An Activist's Diary, Week Ending May 8

Kelly Hammargren
Sunday May 09, 2021 - 09:08:00 PM

The coming week of city meetings looks way more interesting than the one we just finished. Nothing came to a vote at any of the meetings I attended except the Planning Commission, which voted to add five parcels to the Adeline Corridor Plan. You can check the quick summary in The Activist’s Calendar for the meetings deserving your attention this week.

The event I most wanted to attend I missed, because I had not signed up with Eventbrite when I first saw the notice. It is a lesson I’d had before and chose to ignore. Choosing to ignore is the very thing about which this diary will focus.

I had lunch with a fellow vaccinated friend on Friday at one of those street parklets without the plastic walls. We’ve talked about climate many times, but I was most surprised by his response. I am still assimilating the shock that we’ve had 0.4°C of temperature rise (global warming) from 0.8°C in 2018 to 1.2°C in 2020. My friend has long believed we’ve passed the tipping points and are now in feedback loops that are accelerating global warming. His response, he said, he’s stopped watching and reading the news. Instead, he’s reading WWII history.

How many of us are choosing to ignore the signs that are all around us? Or maybe we are paying attention, but have decided that our individual behavior is so insignificant in the global context that it doesn’t matter. So, we can continue to enjoy all those little things, even though when they are combined together as the sum of us they have enormous impact. It’s likely a lot more complicated, and why we choose not to act is what I really wanted to hear, even though the group to the meeting I missed was self-selected to be motivated.

The event I missed was, “Getting Off Gas - Berkeley Electrification Community Meeting” on Tuesday evening. Individually, I am about halfway there to electrification. I have replaced the stove, water heater and furnace and the natural gas line to my house is shut off. I still have my Prius, and I am sorry now I didn’t purchase the hybrid plug-in in 2014. I don’t have solar and I could really beef up the insulation.

I’ve never had a gas clothes dryer and never will. My best friend’s mother suffered a 90% body burn when she turned on the gas clothes dryer and the house exploded. My friend’s mother died three weeks later, the day before her eleventh birthday, three days before mine.

The meeting presentation document is available now and the meeting zoom will be posted soon. https://www.cityofberkeley.info/HPWH/ All the charts and diagrams look great until page 43, the timeline. With 0.4°C of temperature rise in two years do we really have 24 years to get off natural gas in our buildings and fossil fuels altogether? It is this approach that makes me think maybe I just need to crawl into bed with wine and chocolate—of course, if I do that it will likely be with a book on politics or another on nature by Douglas W. Tallamy.

In closing, I finished the book Kill Switch by Adam Jentleson on the filibuster. If I hadn’t committed to reading at least a book a week and knowing that I would close with a note on that reading, I would have stopped a couple chapters in. The book did get better when describing how Senate leaders acquired and wielded power especially Mitch McConnell and Lyndon Johnson. Jesse Helms was the first to use direct mail to fund raise.

There were other interesting stories, but the books that I find to be more important regarding where we are today, in the fraying of this democracy, are: It Was All a Lie: How the Republican Party Became Donald Trump by Stuart Stevens, Twilight of Democracy: The Seductive Lure of Authoritarianism by Anne Applebaum and How Democracies Die by Daniel Ziblatt and Steven Levitsky.

These three books were referenced by Stuart Stevens, Senior Advisor for the Lincoln Project, in his comments on May 5, 2021 in the show All In With Chris Hayes:

“Look, I don`t think this is a tipping point for the Republican Party. I think the Republican Party has tipped. I think it`s a tipping point for America. The greatest danger is not to realize the greatest danger. And what we have here is a moment that appears normal in many ways. We have a normal president who`s going about the business of running a normal, very functional government, but this is an extraordinary moment. 

“And we shouldn`t look to the past to say, OK, it`s just like 1964, it`s just like `68, it`s like `52, because this really never happened in America, at least not since 1860. We should look abroad, like to Hungary. This is a Viktor Orban moment. And what the Republican Party has become, and it`s painful for me to admit this because I spent decades working in it, it has become a major anti-democratic force, little D democratic force in America. 

“It is a dangerous organization that wants to end the American experiment. And the sooner we get about realizing that and understanding it and quit trying to pretend that it`s not, the safer we’ll be and the more we`ll be equipped to deal with it. Because our society is not really ready to deal with what we`re forced to deal with now,... 

It is through the ballot box and through judicial fiat that democracies die…”


Columns

THE PUBLIC EYE:It’s the Jobs, Stupid!

Bob Burnett
Sunday May 09, 2021 - 07:00:00 PM

Judging from the amount of political email I've been receiving, Democrats are running scared, afraid they will lose the 2022 midterm elections. Dems fear that they'll squander a historic opportunity to put America on the right course. Fortunately, it appears that Joe Biden knows what he is doing and he's determined to make job creation the centerpiece of his presidency

If you missed President Biden's April 28th joint address to Congress (https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2021/04/28/remarks-as-prepared-for-delivery-by-president-biden-address-to-a-joint-session-of-congress/ ), you probably didn't hear that he mentioned "jobs" 43 times. He began by acknowledging that his Administration has created 1.3 million jobs in his first 100 days in office. He went on to extol his "American Jobs Plan" and observe: "20 million Americans lost their jobs in the pandemic – working- and middle-class Americans. At the same time, the roughly 650 Billionaires in America saw their net worth increase by more than $1 Trillion... My fellow Americans, trickle-down economics ha never worked. It’s time to grow the economy from the bottom up and middle-out. A broad consensus of economists – left, right, center – agree that what I’m proposing will help create millions of jobs and generate historic economic growth." 

Heading into the 2022 midterm elections, Biden's focus is on three issues: overcoming the coronavirus pandemic, creating millions of good-paying jobs, and strengthening healthcare. This agenda should be achievable in the Democratically-controlled 117th Congress. It will give Democrats strong momentum going into the 2022 midterms. 

The 2010 and 2018 midterms saw a shift in the House of Representatives. Democrats are worried that could happen in 2022. In 2010, Democrats lost the House because of Republican "Tea Party" scare tactics centered on the Affordable Care Act -- most Republicans ran on the promise to "repeal and replace Obamacare." in 2018, Republicans lost the House because Democrats mobilized to take back Congress to check Trump, 

Heading into 2022, Republicans seem to be assuming that they will once again take back the house because of the unstoppable tide of political precedent and the anger of Trump voters. In many states, Republicans are trying to "prime the pump" by gerrymandering and voter suppression. 

Ignoring the notion of "unstoppable political precedent," Republicans are counting on angry Trump voters turning out in record numbers to take back the House. There are two problems with this notion. The first is idea that Republicans will turn out because they are either angry because Trump lost in 2020 or because they don't like what Biden and the Dems have been doing. The second problem is that it is assumes that the voters that Trump brought out in 2020 will show up in 2022. 

In the 2020 presidential election, Donald Trump got 74 million votes -- an unprecedented number for a losing candidate but still 7 million less than Joe Biden. Will these same Republican voters show up in 2022? It seems unlikely for two reasons. First, in 2020 Trump attracted "low-propensity" voters. According to Democratic pollsters (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/byron-yorks-daily-memo-democratic-pollsters-acknowledge-we-darn-near-lost ): "We found our models consistently overestimated Democratic turnout relative to Republican turnout in a specific way... Among low propensity voters -- people who we expect to vote rarely -- the Republican share of the electorate exceeded expectations at four times the rate of the Democratic share. This turnout error meant, at least in some places, we again underestimated relative turnout among rural and white non-college voters, who are overrepresented among low propensity Republicans." Of course, in 2022, Trump will not be on the ballot; therefore, it's unlikely that these Republican low-propensity voters will show up. 

Second, there was a unique combination of circumstances in 2020; including attitudes about the pandemic, GOP enthusiasm for Trump, and the absence of a Democratic "ground game" -- because of the pandemic. In 2022, the circumstances will change. Democrats will again have their ground game. And, they are more likely to be enthusiastic than Republicans. A recent Morning Consult poll (https://morningconsult.com/2021/04/14/voter-enthusiasm-2022-midterms-polling/ ) found that 9 percent enthusiasm advantage among Democrats. (Notably, 31 parent of Trump voters were not enthusiastic.) 

By the way: a recent ABC News/Ipsos Poll ( https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/country-optimistic-bidens-1st-100-days-poll/story?id=77440236) found that 64 percent of respondents were "optimistic" about the direction of the country -- the highest optimism rating in 15 years. 

My contention is that as long as Democrats deliver on the three big issues -- overcoming the coronavirus pandemic, creating millions of good-paying jobs, and strengthening healthcare -- they should prevail in 2022. An election is not solely determined by messaging, but messaging is important. If Democrats stay on the Biden train, they will have positive messaging, In contrast, Republicans do not have a clear message. They cannot prevail with "Trump was cheated" -- by the way, Trump's popularity is falling; a recent NBC news poll (https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/meet-the-press/after-100-days-out-office-trump-s-support-softens-nbc-n1265457) found "His ratings among all adults stands at 32 percent favorable, 55 percent unfavorable." And, at the moment, the GOP has no "go to" message. 

For the next 18 months, Biden and congressional Democrats have one task: focus on the creation of good jobs. 


Bob Burnett is a Bay Area writer and activist. He can be reached at bburnett@sonic.net 


ON MENTAL ILLNESS: There is No Conflict Between Religion and Science

Jack Bragen
Sunday May 09, 2021 - 07:07:00 PM

When members of your church or other religious affiliation dispute the existence of mental illness and advise you not to take psychiatric medication prescribed by a doctor, they're advising you to make a huge mistake. The person advising that will not suffer the consequences themselves, you will. You can be a good Christian, Hindu, Muslim, or any of the above and can still listen to the reality-based warnings and advice from a psychiatrist. A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who specializes in certain brain disorders treatable with psychiatric drugs.

On the other hand, a psychiatrist should never be advising you not to have a religious practice, albeit in my experience I have never seen that happen. Religion and science do not conflict. They are two different things that address completely different areas of human lives. 

Some of the greatest scientists and scholars have been highly religious. Gregor Johann Mendel was a meteorologist, mathematician, biologist, Augustinian friar, and abbot. After his death he gained recognition for discoveries that led to the modern science of genetics. He studied how characteristics in plants were transmitted. In high school, I got the impression that my biology teacher was big into church. I was told by a fellow student that he volunteered at the church doing cleanup. 

You do not have to be atheist to understand and believe science. Our President is highly religious and at the same time touts "listen to the scientists," in his powerful speeches about beating coronavirus. 

I am not religious, but it doesn't mean I lack belief in a higher power. Something takes care of me and got me through dozens of situations that by all rights I should not have survived. The higher power must have work in store for me or would not be taking care of me in this way. When people are in rough times, in which we don't know how we are to get through a situation, even the non-religious like me will be tempted to ask for help from something greater. 

Those who pervert science into something it is not might reject the spiritual, and this leads to cruelty. I am not saying you need to believe in god to be a good person--you do not. My point is that atheistic people who disbelieve in human personhood and believe people are machines that arose by chance, might also reject the validity of human suffering. This could lead to cruel experimentation on people. 

I've heard a psychiatrist say, "consciousness could be an illusion." How crackpot of an idea is that? To assert consciousness is an illusion is in total contradiction to the most basic truth known by a conscious entity: "I think therefore I exist." If consciousness were an illusion, we would be unaware that we are here. Who is reading these words? How is it that you are aware of them? Consciousness is not an illusion; it is a subjective absolute truth. 

Atheism is not the same thing as agnosticism. No one can prove or disprove a theory that explains how the universe came to be. We can prove and disprove many things about the universe and about the people in it. And it has been shown that science is applicable to mental illness. If you are a good Christian, Muslim, Jew, Buddhist, Sikh, other, it doesn't make you more or less likely to become mentally ill, and none of these religions will cure it. 

I once believed meditative attainment could cure my mental illness; it can't. I've gained meditative attainment in my past, and then when I believed it had cured my condition, I relapsed from not taking medication. Afterward I was aware that the attainment I'd created was erased. And it can take years to regain this--if it is even possible. The damage to function that occurs in a relapse of psychosis will make any type of mental development harder to regain. I am not speaking of Buddhism specifically but of mindfulness, which can be practiced generically in the absence of any religious beliefs. 

Many doctors and many psychiatrists seem to reject the notion that human suffering exists. This is a sign of being disconnected. If science is to help the human species, it must be used to remediate aspects of the human condition. It must not be used solely for profits of innovators. Human beings employ massive amounts of time and energy devising methods of getting more. This is also apparently not in conflict with many religious practices. 

Doctors in the U.S. and in NAZI Germany have experimented on human beings. This was perceived as conscionable because people believed they were forwarding science. This is an atrocity like any other. A religious person could do this to people as could a non-religious person. Religion is a separate issue from people's acts of kindness and unkindness. That's an opinion. Many religions teach compassion. Yet the lesson does not always take. Some religions teach members that anyone outside of their religion goes to hell. Some religious people are lacking enough in basic perception that they would not be suitable to practice science. Yet many atheistic people are unsuitable as well, because ruling out the possibility that something conscious could have created the universe shows lack of thought. No one knows how the universe came about. Science can describe the universe but that is all it can do. Religion is not sufficient to explain things either, since our religions create a concept of god from human imagination, not from known fact. 


Jack Bragen is a commentary, self-help and fiction author and lives in Martinez.


SMITHEREENS: Reflections on Bits & Pieces

Gar Smith
Sunday May 09, 2021 - 09:10:00 PM

Meeting the Locals

On my Sunday morning run uphill to the Berkeley Rose Garden, I had an unexpected encounter with one of the local residents. I detected a presence in the street on my right and, when I turned to look, I found myself starring at a young deer. I paused and watched as the deer's four feet passed in front of me—four feet in front of me.

The animal hoof-hopped up the front stairs of the nearest house before diving down between a couple of cars parked in the driveway and heading into the backyard where deer like to linger and munch.

As always, I extended a courteous greeting: "After you, my deer fallow." 

Beer on Raft 

Strolling down Solano Avenue a few nights back, we passed the Kirin Chinese Restaurant And Cocktail Bar and admired the new parklet that now extends into the former parking zone. 

There was a huge banner over the parklet wall that contained a welcoming message. To our amusement, a recent edge-tipping blast of wind had flipped the west end of the banner up and over the print so the invite now read: "RINKS TO GO! Rafted Cocktails!" 

The messed-up message conjured images of ice-skating waitpersons driving Zambonis and paddling kayaks. Guaranteed to draw a crowd. 

Clos Encounters of the Herd Kind 

On a recent morning drive by Berkeley Natural Grocery on Gilman, I couldn't miss the message on the side of a large delivery truck parked nearby. The truck was filled with a load of dairy products from Sonoma's Clover Farms and—for anyone who doesn't know—Clover has a mascot: Clo, a cartoon cow who recently celebrated her 50th anniversary as a pun-grazy commercial icon. 

Checking out the side of the delivery truck, I found a cartoon of Clo holding hooves with a bullish beau as they both traipsed across a hillside wearing 18th century garb. It looked like a bovine version of Wuthering Heights. And the pun, floating overhead/overherd read: "Happily Heifer After." 

(After doing a Clos check of Clover's online archives, I've discovered that this pun actually dates from 2009. Clo's entire list of moosings—viewable online—dates back to 1969.) 

Here's a collection of Clo puns that could leave you feeling cowed. 

"Tip Clo Through Your Two Lips" 

"Born and Grazed in Sonoma" 

"Clo's Knit Community" 

"CLOVER: The Only Milk With LOVE In It" 

"Dancing with the Steers" 

"Dairying to Be Great!" 

"Home Quart Advantage" 

"The Moo the Merrier" 

"Under the MistleClo." 

"Baby, It's Clo Outside." 

"Happy Moo Year!" 

"Sip, Sip, Hooray!" 

"A Scoop Above the Udders." 

"Udderly Devoted to Moo." 

"Talk Dairy To Me." 

PS: Clo even has her own book of children's stories: "Pasture Bedtime." 

Hearts So Full for David Hartsough 

Sunday, May 2nd, marked the 81st birthday for veteran Bay Area Quaker peace activist David Hartsough. 

Like John Lewis, Hartsough knows how to make "good trouble." He has put his body on the line to block US Navy ships headed for Vietnam and ammo trains filled with munitions destined for covert US wars in El Salvador and Nicaragua. He has crossed borders to meet “the enemy” behind the "Iron Curtain" in East Berlin, Castro’s Cuba, and inside present-day Iran. He has marched with victims of violence in Guatemala, stood alongside refugees threatened by Philippine death squads, and handed out stuffed teddy bears to traumatized children in Gaza. 

His book, Waging Peace: Global Adventures of a Lifelong Activist, is testament to the positive change a single individual can accomplish. Inspired by the lives of Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. (with whom he worked during Civil Rights campaigns in The South), Hartsough has spent his life demonstrating how to defuse conflict through the power of active nonviolence. 

In 2002, Hartsough joined Mel Duncan and peace activists from 49 countries to create the Nonviolent Peaceforce. The NP has engaged in civilian peacekeeping missions around the world, training nearly 8,000 volunteers to serve as "unarmed civilian protectors" in far-off hotspots. (NP volunteers are currently active on the ground in Iraq, Myanmar, South Sudan and the Philippines.) 

Hartsough’s story demonstrates the persuasive power of organized nonviolent action. But Waging Peace is more than one man’s memoir. Hartsough shows how nonviolent strategies are being employed all over the world by growing numbers of ordinary people committed to extinguishing the flames of violence and war. 

The broadcast birthday party was special this year since Hartsough has been diagnosed with a bone marrow cancer and chronic leukemia. His extended on-line family of activists repeatedly praised Hartsough for his "relentless persistence" in confronting political violence and predicted he would also be successful in battling (make that "nonviolently resisting") cancer. 

The celebration took the shape of a Sing-a-long that included no fewer than 25 tunes ranging from civil rights anthems and protest ballads to classic Broadway show-tunes. 

After one of the event's many talented musicians completed a stirring rendition of "The Rose," Hartsough and his wife Jan re-appeared onscreen holding a handful of roses they had just plucked from the family garden. The sing-along ended with a rousing chorus of "We Shall Overcome." 

Hundreds of Hartsough's friends and admirers gathered for a memorable dive in the Zoom pool and many of them shared memories of meeting Hartsough in peace actions on nearly every continent. Many of those sharing memories had become life-long friends after meeting Hartsough in college, in high school, in grade school and even in elementary school. 

One of the many well-wishers to log into the Happy Zoomday event was local peace hero Daniel Ellsberg. Noting that Ellsberg's screen was blank, the moderator asked if he could activate his video. 

Ellsberg explained that he had intentionally left his screen blank since he was experiencing a bout of Bell's palsy—a short-term disorder that causes a drooping or swelling of one side of the face. The condition usually passes after a week or so. 

"I look like Dick Cheney!" Ellsberg complained, referencing George W's Vice-Presidential mastermind (or "master," for short). Dick "Darth Vader" Cheney was known for his trademark lop-sided sneer. 

One of the online party-goers interpolated the reassuring news that "Amy Goodman once had a bout of Bell's palsy." 

"Yeah," Ellsberg replied, "but when she looked in a mirror she didn't see Dick Cheney!" 

For updated information on David Hartsough's journey to recovery, you can visit this site at CaringBridge

Ellsberg's Actions Inspire a Mass Response 

And, speaking of Dan Ellsberg: To commemorate the 50th anniversary of the release of the Pentagon Papers (on July 13, 1971), the University of Massachusetts and The GroundTruth Project recently collaborated on a three-day conference dedicated to Truth, Dissent, & the Legacy of Daniel Ellsberg

The conference marked the debut of The Ellsberg Archive Project, a project of UMass' Special Collections & University Archives program. 

In addition to a keynote speech by Daniel Ellsberg, topics addressed during the conference included:
• Why Nuclear Weapons Remain an Existential Threat and What to Do About It
• The American War in Vietnam and Why It Still Matters
• Antiwar Movements Then and Now
• The Pentagon Papers and Watergate
• Whistleblowers: Plenary Panel with Daniel Ellsberg and Edward Snowden
• Lessons and Legacies in an Age of Endless War 

More than 5,700 people registered for the online event and the conference videos have already been viewed more than 14,000 times on the Ellsberg Archive Project website. (UMass is also inviting visitors to check out the GroundTruth Project’s new podcast, The Whistleblower.) 

 

NATO to the Rescue? 

The UK and France have been facing off in a worrisome naval dust-up in the English Channel as part of a long-simmering dispute involving post-Brexit fishing rights in these shared waters. The British Navy dispatched two vessels to the waters off the island of Jersey and France retaliated by deploying two maritime patrol boats. 

The founding principle of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization is that, if any NATO members is attacked, the US is required to come to the assistance of that country. This raises a vexing question. As World BEYOND War founder David Swanson asked during a May 6 webinar: "Does this mean the US now has to attack both France and Britain?" 

The Military Industrial Complex Has Grown More Complex 

Ray McGovern is not your average anti-war campaigner. McGovern is a former Army intelligence officer who worked inside the CIA for 27 years and delivered Daily Presidential Briefs before returning his coveted Intelligence Commendation Medal to protest the CIA's role in torturing foreign captives. In 2003, he co-founded Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity. 

McGovern no longer believes that the US is a democracy. Instead, he warns that the country's economic programs and foreign policy are controlled by a powerful authoritarian elite. And it's no longer just the Military-Industrial Complex (MIC) that President Eisenhower warned us against. These days, as McGovern likes to spell out, we have to deal with the MICIMATTC—"the Military-Industrial-Congressional-Intelligence-Media-Academia-Think-Tank Complex." 

What the Pope Said 

On September 24, 2015, Pope Francis made a historic appearance before the US Congress and offered a fundamental criticism of US foreign policy that somehow failed to make the evening news or the morning papers. Pope Francis had spoken the unspeakable: he condemned America's Military-Industrial Complex and the "many powerful people [who] don't want peace because they live off war." 

“Why are deadly weapons being sold to those who plan to inflict untold suffering on individuals and society? Sadly, the answer, as we all know, is simply for money: money that is drenched in blood, often innocent blood. In the face of this shameful and culpable silence, it is our duty to confront the problem and to stop the arms trade." 

At the time Francis spoke, the US weapons industry had pulled in more than $23.7 billion in weapons sales to nearly 100 different countries. Congressmembers applauded the Pope politely but there was no congressional debate about America's debased role in promoting war for riches. Why? Because in 2014, "defense industry" lobbyists spent more than $150 million on lobbying and direct contributions to the political campaigns of war-friendly politicians. 

In an earlier conversation with a group of Italian primary schoolchildren in May 2015, the Pope had this to say about what he called "the industry of death": 

"Some powerful people make their living with the production of arms and sell them to one country for them to use against another country. The economic system orbits around money and not men, women. … So war is waged in order to defend money. This is why some people don’t want peace: They make more money from war, although wars make money but lose lives, health, education.” 

Seven of the world's ten largest weapons dealers are US companies. The top two are Lockheed Martin and Boeing, followed by Raytheon, Northrop Grumman, General Dynamics, United Technologies, and L-3 Communications. 

 

Letter Literacy 

There is one letter of the English alphabet that doesn't own a proper name. That single, forlorn letter is "w." 

Apparently a late-comer to the alphabet, W bears the name of its nearby neighbor U. But why is W called "double-U"? Why isn't it called "double-V"? 

Why isn't it simply called "wuh"? Did someone fear "wuh" might be confused with "Y"? But "wuh" and "wi" are just as distinguishable as A and I—i.e., "ay" and "eye." 

According to All-knowing Google, the Roman alphabet lacked a letter W. And, apparently, no one needed a W until the Anglo-Saxons came along in the 7th Century AD. Since the letter "v" had not yet been invented (and would have had the wrong sound when if finally did arrive), two "U"s were joined at the hip to represent the "wuh" sound. 

In the 8th Century, the "uu" was retired in favor of a Runic letter known as "wyn." This wyn-wyn situation lasted until the 11th Century, when the Normans conjoined the "uu" into a single letter—our modern-day "double-u." 

Read the Not-Feeling-So-Fine Print 

Have you every glanced at a one-page pharmaceutical ad in a magazine and then paused to read the small print that follows in the next 2-4 pages? 

I haven't kept score but, I swear, in most cases I discover the potential symptoms of the featured drug somehow always manage to include the same conditions the drug is supposed to cure. 

Take Spravato (esketoamine), for example. (Or, considering the side-effects, don't take Spravato.) 

Spavato, a product of Janssen Pharmaceuticals, is a nasal-spray that is introduced as "a different choice" to deal with "treatment-resistant depression." 

So what are the possible downsides of sniffing a strong dose of Spavato? The more prominent symptoms listed include: "worsening depression, thoughts about suicide or dying, suicide attempts." 

Other common warnings point to increased blood pressure, vomiting, feeling drunk, disconnected, sleepy, and dizzy. On the plus side, the small print warned a dose of Spravato just might leave you "feeling very happy or excited." (A sign that the drug also is addictive.) 

In fact (according to the small print), this anti-depressant is so addictive the "your healthcare provider must monitor you for serious side effects for at least 2 hours after taking PRAVATO®." 

But don't blame Spravato. The warnings make the startling admission that, as a general rule, "Antidepressant medicines may increase suicidal thoughts and actions in some people 24 years of age and younger." 


Arts & Events

The Berkeley Activist's Calendar, May 9-16

Kelly Hammargren, Sustainable Berkeley Coalition
Sunday May 09, 2021 - 07:21:00 PM

Worth Noting:

Fire season is here with the first Red Flag Warning from 11 pm Friday until 6 am Monday

Monday - The Agenda and Rules Committee on Monday at 2:30 pm takes up two pages of space. The proposed new commission chart was inserted to make Item 37 easier to read.

Tuesday – Regular City Council meeting at 6 pm has only two action items. Item 29 under ACTION is the Audit of Berkeley Police Response.

Wednesday – Special Transportation meeting at 6 pm on the California/Dwight intersection. The Parks and Waterfront Commission is at 7 pm. The potential fitness court at Cesar Chavez Park that was previously rejected by Parks Commissioners is back again.

Thursday – The Reimagining Public Safety Task Force meets at 6 pm. The Police Review Commission is meeting Thursday at 7 pm not Wednesday.

There are still spots left for the free Virtual Screening of the Rights of Nature Film Invisible Hand and the Q&A with the Directors at 6 pm May 23. Email hammargrenkelly@gmail.com to register for the film and Q&A. Simon Bramwell one of six Extinction Rebellion activists acquitted April 15 in London stated it was wrong that companies and rights and nature didn’t.

If you have a meeting you would like included in the summary of meetings, please send a notice to kellyhammargren@gmail.com by noon on the Friday of the preceding week. 

Sunday, May 9, 2021 - Mother’s Day 

Monday, May 10, 2021 

Agenda and Rules Committee at 2:30 pm, 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89116593118 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (toll free) Meeting ID: 891 1659 3118 

AGENDA: Agenda planning for May 25, CONSENT: 1. Resolution and Ratifying COVID-19 Local Emergency, 2. Minutes for approval, 3. Assessments: Berkeley Tourism Business Improvement District FY22, 4. Assessment: Berkeley Property Owners Business Improvement District - Downtown FY22 & Authorize contract with Downtown Business Association (DBA) $7,285,257 for 7/1/2021-12/31/2026, 5. Assessment: North Shattuck Business Improvement District FY22, 6. Assessment: Telegraph Business Improvement District, 7. Formal Bid Solicitations $250,000, 8. Memorandum of Agreement with the City of Oakland for National Urban Search and Rescue Response System acting through FEMA, Sate and Local governments, 9. Contract $100,000 with Multicultural Institute for COVID-19 Outreach and Health Education Activities 6/1/2021-6/30/2022 outreach to Latinx, particularly day laborer and domestic workers, 10. Revenue Grant Funding Support from Steate of CA Board of State and Community Corrections Proposition 64 Public Health related to Marijuana Act, $1,000,000 5/1/2021-4/30/2024, 11. Revenue Grant Funding Support State of CA Public Health Services, 1-CHDP $353,395, 2-MCAH $332,000, 3-Tobacco $300,000, 4. Immunizations $42,204, 5-Public Heal Emergency Preparedness $257,000, 12. Accept Donation from CA Office of Emergency Services $9,000, 13. Protiviti Government Services: GSA Vehicle for Professional Services, GS-35F-0280X $137,000, 14. Grant Application Surrendered and Abandoned Vessel Exchange (SAVE) $42,000, 15. P.O. $206,180 with Altec Industries, Inc for One (1) Aerial Bucket Truck, 16. P.O. $245,000 with Braun Northwest for One (1) 2021 North Star 155-1 Type 1 Ambulance, 17. P.O. $206,200 with Cal-Line Equipment Inc for three(3) Bandit 250XP Brush Chippers, 18. P.O. $866,000 with Golden State Fire Apparatus, Inc. for one (1)Pierce Quantum 1500 GPM Pumper, 19. Contract add $50,000 total $100,000 with Stanley Access Technologies for On-call and Emergency Repair Service for Automatic Doors, 20. Declaration of Intent – FY22 Street Lighting Assessments, 21. Fund Allocation request to MTC $450,000Transportation Development Act Article 3, 22. Agreement with AC Transit for Operation and Maintenance of transit Signal Priority Equipment deployed by Rapid Corridors Project, 23. Surplus Lands Act AB 1255 requires jurisdictions to compile and report annually an inventory of surplus lands to CA Dept of Housing and Community Development, 24. Lease Agreement: 2010 Addison/Center St Garage with Lexie’s Frozen Custard, 25. Appointment Monica Renee Jones to Mental Health Commission, 26. Authorization for Police Review Commission to conduct online poll, 27. Arreguin-Support AB 1177 CA Banking Options Act (zero fee, zero penalty financial services would eliminate exploitative alternatives such check cashing and pre-paid debit cards), 28. Taplin-Budget Referral Sixth St Traffic Calming 1. Rapid Rectangular Flashing Beacons at Sixth and Channing, 2. Median refuge, 29. Wengraf cosponsors Arreguin, Hahn, Taplin Holocaust Remembrance Day, 30. Wengraf-Budget Referral Traffic Calming increase funding by $100,000 to $200,000, 31. Droste-cosponsors Arreguin, Robinson, Bartlett Budget Referral Willard Park Ambassador, ACTION: 32. FY22 proposed budget hearing #1, final adoption June 29, 33. Public Hearing Environmental Division Fee Schedule adding microenterprise home kitchen operations (MEHKOs) proposed $510 for permit and inspection, 34. Public Hearing Recreation and Camps fee increases, 35. a. Grant Allocation Recommendation for Programs from Sugar Sweetened Beverage Panel of Experts (SSBPE), b. CM approve SSBPE recommendations 1-13 (not 14 & 15) and uphold previously Public Health allocation $339,374. 36.a. Hahn Amend Berkeley Election Reform Act (BERA) to Regulate officeholder accounts, b. Fair Campaign Practices Commission 1-prohibit or regulate officeholder accounts, 37. Droste-cosponsors Kesarwani Robinson, Commission Reorganization for Post-COVID19 Budget Recovery Refer to the CM and City Attorney to bring back changes to the enabling legislation phased approach Phase 1: prioritize merging Homeless Commission & Homeless Services Panel of Experts and merging Housing Advisory Commission & Measure O Bond Oversight Committee, Phase 2: see chart 

Additional considerations Staff to bring forward recommendations on consolidations one by one, CM and commissions to consider federal state or other mandates that might be impacted, what elements to keep, update or retire, relevant topics/issues, number of commissioners, qualifications, standing committees, volunteer workload and capacity.  

Existing Commission 

 

New Commission Name (suggested) 

 

Commission on Climate and the Environment 

(18 members) 

Zero Waste, Energy, Community Environmental Advisory, and Animal Care 

 

Parks, Recreation, Waterfront (special Marina subcommittee) 

 

Children, Youth, and Recreation and Parks and Waterfront 

 

Peace, Justice, and Human Welfare 

(mayor and council appointees only eliminates representatives of the poor) 

Peace and Justice Commission and Human Welfare and Community Action Commission 

 

Public Health Commission & Sugar Sweetened Beverage Panel of Experts 

 

Community Health Commission and Sugar Sweetened Beverage Panel of Experts 

 

Housing Advisory Commission 

(Phase 1 priority consolidation) 

Measure O and Housing Advisory Commission 

 

Homeless Services Panel of Experts 

(Phase 1 priority consolidation) 

Homeless Commission and Measure P Homeless Services Panel of Experts 

 

Public Works and Transportation 

 

Public Works and Transportation 

 

Planning 

 

Planning and Cannabis 

All other commissions will maintain their current structure: Aging, Library Board of Trustees, Civic Arts, Disability, Commission on the Status of Women, Design Review Committee, Disaster and Fire Safety, BIDs, Fair Campaign Practices and Open Government, Redistricting, Landmarks Preservation, Labor, Loan Adjustments Board, Personnel, Planning, Police Review/Accountability, Reimagining Public Safety, Mental Health, Zoning Adjustments Board, and Youth 

38. Hahn-COVID Economic Recovery-Expanding Local Purchasing Preferences to Rebuild the City’s Local Economy Tax Base, 39. Wengraf-Amend BMC14.72.105 allow broader range of community facilities to be eligible for parking permits. INFORMATION: 40. Mental Health Work Plan, CONSENT: REFERRED ITEMS for REVIEW: 8. Discussion Regarding Impact of COVID-19 on Meetings, UNSCHEDULED ITEMS: 9. Strengthening and Supporting Commissions, Unfinished Business for Scheduling: 1. Kitchen Exhaust Hood Ventilation, 2. Surveillance Technology, 3. Objective Standards Recommendations for Density, Design and Shadows. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/City_Council/Policy_Committee__Agenda___Rules.aspx 

Youth Commission at 5 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/97392842150 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 973 9284 2150 

AGENDA: 5. Public Comment, Chair announcements, Director’s Report, 8. City of Berkeley Teen Vaccination Campaign, 9. Election Chair, 10. Introductions, 11. Discussion Trigger Warnings, 12-14 Appointments to subcommittees, 18. Vice Mayor Lori Droste. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Youth_Commission_Homepage.aspx 

Tuesday, May 11 2021 

City Council Regular Meeting at 6 pm, 

Email comments to council@cityofberkeley.info 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84138848278 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (toll free) Meeting ID: 841 3884 8278 

AGENDA CONSENT: 1. 2nd reading Ordinance Regulating Police acquisition and Use of Controlled Equipment, 2. FY2021 Annual Appropriations $76,221,382 (gross) $51,227,368 (net), 3. Formal Bid Solicitations $1,800,000 ($1,100,000 Dock O&K Electrical upgrade, $700,000 Community partnerships COVID-19 testing, quarantine and vaccine), 4. Contract $300,000 7/1/2021-6/30/2022 with The Wright Institute for Mental Health Counseling for older adults, 5. Add $146,304 total $355,822 thru 6/30/2022 with Pacific Site Management for Landscaping services, 6. Add $245,000 total $637,778 thru 6/30/2021 (to be carried over to FY 2022 and then encumbered) with BUSD to provide Mental Health Services Act funded programs, 7. Add $55,000 total $90,000 thru 6/1/2021-6-30/2022 with GoGoGrandparent Technologies for Transportation Services for Senior and the Disabled, 8. Revenue Grant application funding from Alameda Co. for Public Health Services FY2022 ($93,187 Foster Care, $178,778 Berkeley High & Berkeley Tech, $193,175 school linked Measure A, $76,290 Tobacco Prevention), 9. Revenue Grant application to Essential Access Health for $180,000 for public health promotion, 10. Salary Resolution SEIU 1021 Accountant II hourly range $45.6375-$54.1916, 11. Add $209,980 total $614,980 extend term 5/14/2021- 6/30/2024, 12. Mills contract 1 Orchard Lane, 13. Mills contract 1581 LeRoy Ave, 14. Amend 1956 Maintenance Agreement with Caltrans – transfer two portions of City’s right of way on Gilman to Caltrans, 15. Arreguin co-sponsors Droste, Bartlett, Robinson – Support AB 550 Speed Safety cameras and request Berkeley be included as one of the pilot cities, 16. Arreguin co-sponsors Wengraf, Hahn, Kesarwani- AB 43 Safe Streets gives cities flexibility in reducing speed limits, 17. Arreguin co-sponsor Kesarwani – Support AB 629 require MTC to designate transit priority corridors and create pilot of multi-operator transit fare passes, 18. Arreguin - Amending COVID-19 Emergency Response Ordinance Relating to Commercial Leases, 19. Arreguin – Resolution committing to the C40 race to Zero www.citiesracetozero.org Berkeley to be carbon neutral/net zero by 2045 – global warming was 0.8°C in 2018 and ≈1.2°C in 2020 major action needed worldwide to stay at or below global warming of 1.5°C, 20. Taplin - Proclaim May 2021 as Mental Health Month, 21. Taplin co-sponsor Hahn – Resolution in support of Green New Deal for Cities 2021, 22. Taplin – Budget Referral Traffic Calming at Ashby & California, Sacramento & Channing, Cedar & 9th, 6th & Channing, Sacramento & Russell, Channing & San Pablo, 23. Harrison co-sponsor Hahn – Support Roadmap Home 2030 Plan (Home 2030 funders include Chan Zuckerberg Initiative), 24. Hahn, co-sponsors- Harrison, Arreguin – Support AB 1289 Smart Climate Agriculture and AB 558 CA School Plant-based Food and Beverage Program, 25. Wengraf, co-sponsors Kesarwani, Harrison – Support SB-15 rezone idle retail sites to allow for affordable housing, 26. Robinson cosponsors Hahn, Wengraf Support Senator Warren’s Student Loan Debt Relief, 27. Robinson co-sponsors Bartlett, Droste, Arreguin – Support AB 1238 & AB 122 repeal jaywalking laws and bicyclists to treat stop signs as yield signs, ACTION: 28. Published charges: Mental Health Clinical Services, 29. Audit Report: Data Analysis of City of Berkeley’s Police Response, INFORMATION: 30. Energy Commission Work Plan, 31. Streets Audit Wins National Recognition. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/City_Council/City_Council__Agenda_Index.aspx 

Wednesday, May 12 2021 

Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board at 10 – 11:30 am 

Requires pre-registration use link 

AGENDA: Rent Board Registration 101, Registering Your Rental Property. 

http://www.cityofberkeley.info/rent/ 

Homeless Commission at 7 – 9 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/96645301465 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 966 4530 1465 

AGENDA: 2. Public Comment, 5. Updates, 6. Discussion of Possible Homeless Ombudsman Position, 7. Accessibility Update at Pathways, 8. Update Homeless Panel of Experts Recommendations for Measure P Spending. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Homeless_Commission_Homepage.aspx 

Housing Advisory Commission Special meeting at 6 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/96267647237 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 962 6764 7237 

AGENDA: 3. Public Comment, 6. Discussion and Action on West Berkeley Service Center’s Application for COB Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) 

http://www.cityofberkeley.info/Housing_Advisory_Commission/ 

Parks and Waterfront Commission at 7 – 9 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/96974512296 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 969 7451 2296 

AGENDA: 5. Public Comment, 6. Chair’s Report, Director’s Report, 8. Presentation: Annual Western Monarch Butterfly Monitoring at Aquatic Park, 9. Discussion/Action potential fitness at Cesar Chavez Park, 10. PRW/Operation Budget, 11. Update on Proposed Ferry/Pier Project & BMASP, 12. Refuse Service Parks/Marina 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Parks_and_Waterfront_Commission.aspx 

Dwight Way/California Street Intersection Project at 6 pm 

Zoom and links will be posted on city website on May 12,  

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/californiadwight/ 

Agenda: Project features on webpage 

Thursday, May 13, 2021 

City Council Closed Session at 3 pm 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89118687489 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (toll free) Meeting ID: 891 1868 7489 

AGENDA: 1. Conference with Labor Negotiators for IBEW, Local 1245, SEIU 1021 Community Services and Part-time Recreation Activity Leaders, Berkeley Fire Fighters Local 1227, Berkeley Police Association, SEIU 1021 Maintenance and Clerical Chapters, Berkeley Fire Chiefs Association Public Employees Local 1. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/City_Council/City_Council__Agenda_Index.aspx 

Police Review Commission at 7 – 10 pm, (note meeting is scheduled for Thursday, May 13) 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87070468124 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 870 7046 8124 

AGENDA: 3. Public Comment on agenda and non-agenda items, 5. Chair Report, 6. PRC Officer Report, 7. Police Chief report, 8. Subcommittee reports, 9. a. Consider draft Policy 606, Warrant Service, b. Review BPD issues implementing Policy 300 Use of Force, c. Whether participate in scenario-based use-of-force training, d. Whether commissioners may be allowed to observe police officers being trained in use, e. Update transition to Police Accountability Board and Director of Police Accountability, 10.a. Consider making recommendations to new Board for handling complaints, b. Discuss vaccination status sworn officers, c. Lexipol policies: 324-Media Policies, 403-Crime and Disaster Scene Integrity and Investigation, 804-Records Maintenance and Release. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Police_Review_Commission_Homepage.aspx 

Zoning Adjustment Board at 7 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/98029164696 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 980 2916 4696 

AGENDA: 2. 1730 Blake – on consent– construct one 3-story, single family dwelling average and maximum height 33 ft, zoning R-2 - 2nd house on parcel 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/zoningadjustmentsboard/ 

Reimagining Public Safety Task Force at 6 pm 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81983354907 (this link was created using the meeting ID, the zoom link posted with the agenda is expired, look for a corrected zoom link in agenda after Monday. Expect it to be the same as the one here created using the meeting ID) 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 Meeting ID: 819 8335 4907 

AGENDA: 2. Public Comment, Discussion/Action: Police Dept Overview #2 (Interim Chief Jennifer Lewis), Specialized Care Unit (Dr. Lisa Warhuus), Community Survey (NICJR), Community Engagement (NICJR), Subcommittee Reports: Policing, Budget & Alternatives to Policing (Opton, Ghosh, Cheema, Dangerfield, Lindheim, Mizell, Harger, Hyde) Cummunity Engagement (Fine, Harger, Malvido, Lutzker, Ejigu, Blake) 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/RIPST.aspx 

AC Transit Talks, 6 pm – 7:30 pm 

Use website for all links: https://www.actransit.org/talks 

AGENDA: Purpose of meetings to provide community updates on bus service, health and safety and communicate with Board Directors Jovanka Beckles for Richmond/North Richmond/San Pablo/Albany/Berkeley/Kensington/El Sorbrante 

Friday, May 14, 2021 

Reduced Service Day 

Saturday, May 15, 2021 & Sunday, May 16, 2021 

No City meetings or events found 

_____________________ 

Public Hearings Scheduled – Land Use Appeals 

2421 Fifth Street (construct two residential buildings) 6/1/2021 

1205 Peralta (conversion of garage) TBD 

2943 Pine (construct a 2nd story) TBD 

Notice of Decision (NOD) and Use Permits with End of Appeal Period 

3107 Deakin 5/18/2021 

1733 Fourth (Convert retail space to auto sales) 5/19/2021 

1733 Fourth (alterations to building) 5/13/2021 

2110 Haste 5/10/2021 

1231 Ordway 5/19/2021 

1913 San Antonio 5/19/2021 

1633 Sixth 5/12/2021 

2411 Sixth 5/25/2021 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Planning_and_Development/Land_Use_Division/Current_Zoning_Applications_in_Appeal_Period.aspx 

LINK to Current Zoning Applications https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Planning_and_Development/Land_Use_Division/Current_Zoning_Applications.aspx 

___________________ 

WORKSESSIONS 

May 18 – 1. Systems Realignment 2. Affordable Housing Policy Reform (tentative) 

July 20 – 1. Bayer Development Agreement (tentative), 2. Measure FF/Fire Prevention 

September 21 – 1. Housing Element (RHNA) 

Unscheduled Workshops/Presentations 

Cannabis Health Considerations 

Berkeley Police Department Hiring Practices (referred by Public Safety Committee) 

Update Zero Waste Priorities 

Civic Arts Grantmaking Process & Capital Grant Program 

Review and Update on City’s COVID-19 Response 

This meeting list is also posted on the Sustainable Berkeley Coalition website. 

http://www.sustainableberkeleycoalition.com/whats-ahead.html and in the Berkeley Daily Planet under activist’s calendar http://www.berkeleydailyplanet.com 

If you or someone you know wishes to receive the weekly summary as soon as it is completed, email kellyhammargren@gmail.com to be added to the early email list. 

If you wish to stop receiving the Weekly Summary of City Meetings please 

forward the weekly summary you received to kellyhammargren@gmail.com 

***************************** 

Free Virtual Screening of the Rights of Nature film  

Invisible Hand 

and Q&A with the directors 

sponsored by Sustainable Berkeley Coalition and Berkeley Citizens Action  

 

Register at 

https://www.invisiblehandfilm.com/berkeley-give-nature-a-chance/ 

via email to hammargrenkelly@gmail.com 

early registration is recommended 

the free virtual screening and Q&A is limited to 100 participants 

If you have any questions contact Kelly Hammargren at hammargrenkelly@gmail.com 

 

Q&A with the directors: 6 pm, Sunday, May 23. 

The 85 minute documentary film is available for viewing from  

4:00 pm PDT Saturday, May 22 to Sunday, May 23, 6 pm PDT 

Audiences have said INVISIBLE HAND is a “game changing” story about Rights of Nature and global battle between capitalism and democracy. Last Born in the Wilderness host Patrick Farnsworth has called the film “really, really beautiful” and “incredibly moving.” 

“We are honored to receive these awards for documenting the Rights of Nature story,” said Pribanic. “This is a turning point in the story of our culture, where the Indigenous legacy that once protected this land can resurface to take on capitalism and defend Nature’s rights.” 

What this documentary is offering is a way forward through Rights of Nature. You hear time and time again that a corporation has the rights of a person. The idea that Nature has no rights whatsoever is absurd,” ~ Mark Ruffalo

The Rights of Nature in Berkeley  

The Resolution to Recognize the Rights of Nature is submitted by Councilmember Cheryl Davila for consideration by the Berkeley City Council at the October 27, 2020 City Council regular meeting.  

On October 13, 2020, the Berkeley City Council Agenda and Policy Committee removed Recognize the Rights of Nature from the proposed October 27, 2020 City Council agenda and referred the item to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment and Sustainability Policy Committee (FITES).  

On March 3, 2021 FITES voted to forward the Rights of Nature to the full City Council with a qualified positive recommendation the final resolved clause of the draft resolution to place obligation on the City not the residents.  

On March 15 at the Agenda and Rules Policy Committee Mayor Arreguin said he was opposed to recognizing the rights of nature. 

The item was left on the council agenda for March 30.  

At the March 30 council meeting Mayor Arreguin said he supported the Rights of Nature and recommended moving the item to the consent calendar as a referral to the Peace and Justice Commission.  

At the same meeting after the consent vote approving the referral, the City Manager stated the Peace and Justice Commission would not be meeting because staff supporting the Peace and Justice Commission had been reassigned to support the EOC (Emergency Operation Center) for the COVID-19 emergency. 

Rights of Nature, legislative examples, history, timeline, documents and references,  

https://www.invisiblehandfilm.com/what-are-rights-of-nature/ 

Worth Noting: 

Fire season is here with the first Red Flag Warning from 11 pm Friday until 6 am Monday 

Monday - The Agenda and Rules Committee on Monday at 2:30 pm takes up two pages of space. The proposed new commission chart was inserted to make Item 37 easier to read. 

Tuesday – Regular City Council meeting at 6 pm has only two action items. Item 29 under ACTION is the Audit of Berkeley Police Response. 

Wednesday – Special Transportation meeting at 6 pm on the California/Dwight intersection. The Parks and Waterfront Commission is at 7 pm. The potential fitness court at Cesar Chavez Park that was previously rejected by Parks Commissioners is back again. 

Thursday – The Reimagining Public Safety Task Force meets at 6 pm. The Police Review Commission is meeting Thursday at 7 pm not Wednesday. 

There are still spots left for the free Virtual Screening of the Rights of Nature Film Invisible Hand and the Q&A with the Directors at 6 pm May 23. Email hammargrenkelly@gmail.com to register for the film and Q&A. Simon Bramwell one of six Extinction Rebellion activists acquitted April 15 in London stated it was wrong that companies and rights and nature didn’t. 

If you have a meeting you would like included in the summary of meetings, please send a notice to kellyhammargren@gmail.com by noon on the Friday of the preceding week. 

Sunday, May 9, 2021 - Mother’s Day 

Monday, May 10, 2021 

Agenda and Rules Committee at 2:30 pm, 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89116593118 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (toll free) Meeting ID: 891 1659 3118 

AGENDA: Agenda planning for May 25, CONSENT: 1. Resolution and Ratifying COVID-19 Local Emergency, 2. Minutes for approval, 3. Assessments: Berkeley Tourism Business Improvement District FY22, 4. Assessment: Berkeley Property Owners Business Improvement District - Downtown FY22 & Authorize contract with Downtown Business Association (DBA) $7,285,257 for 7/1/2021-12/31/2026, 5. Assessment: North Shattuck Business Improvement District FY22, 6. Assessment: Telegraph Business Improvement District, 7. Formal Bid Solicitations $250,000, 8. Memorandum of Agreement with the City of Oakland for National Urban Search and Rescue Response System acting through FEMA, Sate and Local governments, 9. Contract $100,000 with Multicultural Institute for COVID-19 Outreach and Health Education Activities 6/1/2021-6/30/2022 outreach to Latinx, particularly day laborer and domestic workers, 10. Revenue Grant Funding Support from Steate of CA Board of State and Community Corrections Proposition 64 Public Health related to Marijuana Act, $1,000,000 5/1/2021-4/30/2024, 11. Revenue Grant Funding Support State of CA Public Health Services, 1-CHDP $353,395, 2-MCAH $332,000, 3-Tobacco $300,000, 4. Immunizations $42,204, 5-Public Heal Emergency Preparedness $257,000, 12. Accept Donation from CA Office of Emergency Services $9,000, 13. Protiviti Government Services: GSA Vehicle for Professional Services, GS-35F-0280X $137,000, 14. Grant Application Surrendered and Abandoned Vessel Exchange (SAVE) $42,000, 15. P.O. $206,180 with Altec Industries, Inc for One (1) Aerial Bucket Truck, 16. P.O. $245,000 with Braun Northwest for One (1) 2021 North Star 155-1 Type 1 Ambulance, 17. P.O. $206,200 with Cal-Line Equipment Inc for three(3) Bandit 250XP Brush Chippers, 18. P.O. $866,000 with Golden State Fire Apparatus, Inc. for one (1)Pierce Quantum 1500 GPM Pumper, 19. Contract add $50,000 total $100,000 with Stanley Access Technologies for On-call and Emergency Repair Service for Automatic Doors, 20. Declaration of Intent – FY22 Street Lighting Assessments, 21. Fund Allocation request to MTC $450,000Transportation Development Act Article 3, 22. Agreement with AC Transit for Operation and Maintenance of transit Signal Priority Equipment deployed by Rapid Corridors Project, 23. Surplus Lands Act AB 1255 requires jurisdictions to compile and report annually an inventory of surplus lands to CA Dept of Housing and Community Development, 24. Lease Agreement: 2010 Addison/Center St Garage with Lexie’s Frozen Custard, 25. Appointment Monica Renee Jones to Mental Health Commission, 26. Authorization for Police Review Commission to conduct online poll, 27. Arreguin-Support AB 1177 CA Banking Options Act (zero fee, zero penalty financial services would eliminate exploitative alternatives such check cashing and pre-paid debit cards), 28. Taplin-Budget Referral Sixth St Traffic Calming 1. Rapid Rectangular Flashing Beacons at Sixth and Channing, 2. Median refuge, 29. Wengraf cosponsors Arreguin, Hahn, Taplin Holocaust Remembrance Day, 30. Wengraf-Budget Referral Traffic Calming increase funding by $100,000 to $200,000, 31. Droste-cosponsors Arreguin, Robinson, Bartlett Budget Referral Willard Park Ambassador, ACTION: 32. FY22 proposed budget hearing #1, final adoption June 29, 33. Public Hearing Environmental Division Fee Schedule adding microenterprise home kitchen operations (MEHKOs) proposed $510 for permit and inspection, 34. Public Hearing Recreation and Camps fee increases, 35. a. Grant Allocation Recommendation for Programs from Sugar Sweetened Beverage Panel of Experts (SSBPE), b. CM approve SSBPE recommendations 1-13 (not 14 & 15) and uphold previously Public Health allocation $339,374. 36.a. Hahn Amend Berkeley Election Reform Act (BERA) to Regulate officeholder accounts, b. Fair Campaign Practices Commission 1-prohibit or regulate officeholder accounts, 37. Droste-cosponsors Kesarwani Robinson, Commission Reorganization for Post-COVID19 Budget Recovery Refer to the CM and City Attorney to bring back changes to the enabling legislation phased approach Phase 1: prioritize merging Homeless Commission & Homeless Services Panel of Experts and merging Housing Advisory Commission & Measure O Bond Oversight Committee, Phase 2: see chart 

Additional considerations Staff to bring forward recommendations on consolidations one by one, CM and commissions to consider federal state or other mandates that might be impacted, what elements to keep, update or retire, relevant topics/issues, number of commissioners, qualifications, standing committees, volunteer workload and capacity.  

Existing Commission 

 

New Commission Name (suggested) 

 

Commission on Climate and the Environment 

(18 members) 

Zero Waste, Energy, Community Environmental Advisory, and Animal Care 

 

Parks, Recreation, Waterfront (special Marina subcommittee) 

 

Children, Youth, and Recreation and Parks and Waterfront 

 

Peace, Justice, and Human Welfare 

(mayor and council appointees only eliminates representatives of the poor) 

Peace and Justice Commission and Human Welfare and Community Action Commission 

 

Public Health Commission & Sugar Sweetened Beverage Panel of Experts 

 

Community Health Commission and Sugar Sweetened Beverage Panel of Experts 

 

Housing Advisory Commission 

(Phase 1 priority consolidation) 

Measure O and Housing Advisory Commission 

 

Homeless Services Panel of Experts 

(Phase 1 priority consolidation) 

Homeless Commission and Measure P Homeless Services Panel of Experts 

 

Public Works and Transportation 

 

Public Works and Transportation 

 

Planning 

 

Planning and Cannabis 

All other commissions will maintain their current structure: Aging, Library Board of Trustees, Civic Arts, Disability, Commission on the Status of Women, Design Review Committee, Disaster and Fire Safety, BIDs, Fair Campaign Practices and Open Government, Redistricting, Landmarks Preservation, Labor, Loan Adjustments Board, Personnel, Planning, Police Review/Accountability, Reimagining Public Safety, Mental Health, Zoning Adjustments Board, and Youth 

38. Hahn-COVID Economic Recovery-Expanding Local Purchasing Preferences to Rebuild the City’s Local Economy Tax Base, 39. Wengraf-Amend BMC14.72.105 allow broader range of community facilities to be eligible for parking permits. INFORMATION: 40. Mental Health Work Plan, CONSENT: REFERRED ITEMS for REVIEW: 8. Discussion Regarding Impact of COVID-19 on Meetings, UNSCHEDULED ITEMS: 9. Strengthening and Supporting Commissions, Unfinished Business for Scheduling: 1. Kitchen Exhaust Hood Ventilation, 2. Surveillance Technology, 3. Objective Standards Recommendations for Density, Design and Shadows. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/City_Council/Policy_Committee__Agenda___Rules.aspx 

Youth Commission at 5 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/97392842150 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 973 9284 2150 

AGENDA: 5. Public Comment, Chair announcements, Director’s Report, 8. City of Berkeley Teen Vaccination Campaign, 9. Election Chair, 10. Introductions, 11. Discussion Trigger Warnings, 12-14 Appointments to subcommittees, 18. Vice Mayor Lori Droste. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Youth_Commission_Homepage.aspx 

Tuesday, May 11 2021 

City Council Regular Meeting at 6 pm, 

Email comments to council@cityofberkeley.info 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84138848278 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (toll free) Meeting ID: 841 3884 8278 

AGENDA CONSENT: 1. 2nd reading Ordinance Regulating Police acquisition and Use of Controlled Equipment, 2. FY2021 Annual Appropriations $76,221,382 (gross) $51,227,368 (net), 3. Formal Bid Solicitations $1,800,000 ($1,100,000 Dock O&K Electrical upgrade, $700,000 Community partnerships COVID-19 testing, quarantine and vaccine), 4. Contract $300,000 7/1/2021-6/30/2022 with The Wright Institute for Mental Health Counseling for older adults, 5. Add $146,304 total $355,822 thru 6/30/2022 with Pacific Site Management for Landscaping services, 6. Add $245,000 total $637,778 thru 6/30/2021 (to be carried over to FY 2022 and then encumbered) with BUSD to provide Mental Health Services Act funded programs, 7. Add $55,000 total $90,000 thru 6/1/2021-6-30/2022 with GoGoGrandparent Technologies for Transportation Services for Senior and the Disabled, 8. Revenue Grant application funding from Alameda Co. for Public Health Services FY2022 ($93,187 Foster Care, $178,778 Berkeley High & Berkeley Tech, $193,175 school linked Measure A, $76,290 Tobacco Prevention), 9. Revenue Grant application to Essential Access Health for $180,000 for public health promotion, 10. Salary Resolution SEIU 1021 Accountant II hourly range $45.6375-$54.1916, 11. Add $209,980 total $614,980 extend term 5/14/2021- 6/30/2024, 12. Mills contract 1 Orchard Lane, 13. Mills contract 1581 LeRoy Ave, 14. Amend 1956 Maintenance Agreement with Caltrans – transfer two portions of City’s right of way on Gilman to Caltrans, 15. Arreguin co-sponsors Droste, Bartlett, Robinson – Support AB 550 Speed Safety cameras and request Berkeley be included as one of the pilot cities, 16. Arreguin co-sponsors Wengraf, Hahn, Kesarwani- AB 43 Safe Streets gives cities flexibility in reducing speed limits, 17. Arreguin co-sponsor Kesarwani – Support AB 629 require MTC to designate transit priority corridors and create pilot of multi-operator transit fare passes, 18. Arreguin - Amending COVID-19 Emergency Response Ordinance Relating to Commercial Leases, 19. Arreguin – Resolution committing to the C40 race to Zero www.citiesracetozero.org Berkeley to be carbon neutral/net zero by 2045 – global warming was 0.8°C in 2018 and ≈1.2°C in 2020 major action needed worldwide to stay at or below global warming of 1.5°C, 20. Taplin - Proclaim May 2021 as Mental Health Month, 21. Taplin co-sponsor Hahn – Resolution in support of Green New Deal for Cities 2021, 22. Taplin – Budget Referral Traffic Calming at Ashby & California, Sacramento & Channing, Cedar & 9th, 6th & Channing, Sacramento & Russell, Channing & San Pablo, 23. Harrison co-sponsor Hahn – Support Roadmap Home 2030 Plan (Home 2030 funders include Chan Zuckerberg Initiative), 24. Hahn, co-sponsors- Harrison, Arreguin – Support AB 1289 Smart Climate Agriculture and AB 558 CA School Plant-based Food and Beverage Program, 25. Wengraf, co-sponsors Kesarwani, Harrison – Support SB-15 rezone idle retail sites to allow for affordable housing, 26. Robinson cosponsors Hahn, Wengraf Support Senator Warren’s Student Loan Debt Relief, 27. Robinson co-sponsors Bartlett, Droste, Arreguin – Support AB 1238 & AB 122 repeal jaywalking laws and bicyclists to treat stop signs as yield signs, ACTION: 28. Published charges: Mental Health Clinical Services, 29. Audit Report: Data Analysis of City of Berkeley’s Police Response, INFORMATION: 30. Energy Commission Work Plan, 31. Streets Audit Wins National Recognition. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/City_Council/City_Council__Agenda_Index.aspx 

Wednesday, May 12 2021 

Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board at 10 – 11:30 am 

Requires pre-registration use link 

AGENDA: Rent Board Registration 101, Registering Your Rental Property. 

http://www.cityofberkeley.info/rent/ 

Homeless Commission at 7 – 9 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/96645301465 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 966 4530 1465 

AGENDA: 2. Public Comment, 5. Updates, 6. Discussion of Possible Homeless Ombudsman Position, 7. Accessibility Update at Pathways, 8. Update Homeless Panel of Experts Recommendations for Measure P Spending. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Homeless_Commission_Homepage.aspx 

Housing Advisory Commission Special meeting at 6 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/96267647237 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 962 6764 7237 

AGENDA: 3. Public Comment, 6. Discussion and Action on West Berkeley Service Center’s Application for COB Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) 

http://www.cityofberkeley.info/Housing_Advisory_Commission/ 

Parks and Waterfront Commission at 7 – 9 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/96974512296 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 969 7451 2296 

AGENDA: 5. Public Comment, 6. Chair’s Report, Director’s Report, 8. Presentation: Annual Western Monarch Butterfly Monitoring at Aquatic Park, 9. Discussion/Action potential fitness at Cesar Chavez Park, 10. PRW/Operation Budget, 11. Update on Proposed Ferry/Pier Project & BMASP, 12. Refuse Service Parks/Marina 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Parks_and_Waterfront_Commission.aspx 

Dwight Way/California Street Intersection Project at 6 pm 

Zoom and links will be posted on city website on May 12,  

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/californiadwight/ 

Agenda: Project features on webpage 

Thursday, May 13, 2021 

City Council Closed Session at 3 pm 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89118687489 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 or 1-877-853-5257 (toll free) Meeting ID: 891 1868 7489 

AGENDA: 1. Conference with Labor Negotiators for IBEW, Local 1245, SEIU 1021 Community Services and Part-time Recreation Activity Leaders, Berkeley Fire Fighters Local 1227, Berkeley Police Association, SEIU 1021 Maintenance and Clerical Chapters, Berkeley Fire Chiefs Association Public Employees Local 1. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/City_Council/City_Council__Agenda_Index.aspx 

Police Review Commission at 7 – 10 pm, (note meeting is scheduled for Thursday, May 13) 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87070468124 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 870 7046 8124 

AGENDA: 3. Public Comment on agenda and non-agenda items, 5. Chair Report, 6. PRC Officer Report, 7. Police Chief report, 8. Subcommittee reports, 9. a. Consider draft Policy 606, Warrant Service, b. Review BPD issues implementing Policy 300 Use of Force, c. Whether participate in scenario-based use-of-force training, d. Whether commissioners may be allowed to observe police officers being trained in use, e. Update transition to Police Accountability Board and Director of Police Accountability, 10.a. Consider making recommendations to new Board for handling complaints, b. Discuss vaccination status sworn officers, c. Lexipol policies: 324-Media Policies, 403-Crime and Disaster Scene Integrity and Investigation, 804-Records Maintenance and Release. 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Clerk/Commissions/Commissions__Police_Review_Commission_Homepage.aspx 

Zoning Adjustment Board at 7 pm 

Videoconference: https://zoom.us/j/98029164696 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-6833 Meeting ID: 980 2916 4696 

AGENDA: 2. 1730 Blake – on consent– construct one 3-story, single family dwelling average and maximum height 33 ft, zoning R-2 - 2nd house on parcel 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/zoningadjustmentsboard/ 

Reimagining Public Safety Task Force at 6 pm 

Videoconference: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81983354907 (this link was created using the meeting ID, the zoom link posted with the agenda is expired, look for a corrected zoom link in agenda after Monday. Expect it to be the same as the one here created using the meeting ID) 

Teleconference: 1-669-900-9128 Meeting ID: 819 8335 4907 

AGENDA: 2. Public Comment, Discussion/Action: Police Dept Overview #2 (Interim Chief Jennifer Lewis), Specialized Care Unit (Dr. Lisa Warhuus), Community Survey (NICJR), Community Engagement (NICJR), Subcommittee Reports: Policing, Budget & Alternatives to Policing (Opton, Ghosh, Cheema, Dangerfield, Lindheim, Mizell, Harger, Hyde) Cummunity Engagement (Fine, Harger, Malvido, Lutzker, Ejigu, Blake) 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/RIPST.aspx 

AC Transit Talks, 6 pm – 7:30 pm 

Use website for all links: https://www.actransit.org/talks 

AGENDA: Purpose of meetings to provide community updates on bus service, health and safety and communicate with Board Directors Jovanka Beckles for Richmond/North Richmond/San Pablo/Albany/Berkeley/Kensington/El Sorbrante 

Friday, May 14, 2021 

Reduced Service Day 

Saturday, May 15, 2021 & Sunday, May 16, 2021 

No City meetings or events found 

_____________________ 

Public Hearings Scheduled – Land Use Appeals 

2421 Fifth Street (construct two residential buildings) 6/1/2021 

1205 Peralta (conversion of garage) TBD 

2943 Pine (construct a 2nd story) TBD 

Notice of Decision (NOD) and Use Permits with End of Appeal Period 

3107 Deakin 5/18/2021 

1733 Fourth (Convert retail space to auto sales) 5/19/2021 

1733 Fourth (alterations to building) 5/13/2021 

2110 Haste 5/10/2021 

1231 Ordway 5/19/2021 

1913 San Antonio 5/19/2021 

1633 Sixth 5/12/2021 

2411 Sixth 5/25/2021 

https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Planning_and_Development/Land_Use_Division/Current_Zoning_Applications_in_Appeal_Period.aspx 

LINK to Current Zoning Applications https://www.cityofberkeley.info/Planning_and_Development/Land_Use_Division/Current_Zoning_Applications.aspx 

___________________ 

WORKSESSIONS 

May 18 – 1. Systems Realignment 2. Affordable Housing Policy Reform (tentative) 

July 20 – 1. Bayer Development Agreement (tentative), 2. Measure FF/Fire Prevention 

September 21 – 1. Housing Element (RHNA) 

Unscheduled Workshops/Presentations 

Cannabis Health Considerations 

Berkeley Police Department Hiring Practices (referred by Public Safety Committee) 

Update Zero Waste Priorities 

Civic Arts Grantmaking Process & Capital Grant Program 

Review and Update on City’s COVID-19 Response 

This meeting list is also posted on the Sustainable Berkeley Coalition website. 

http://www.sustainableberkeleycoalition.com/whats-ahead.html and in the Berkeley Daily Planet under activist’s calendar http://www.berkeleydailyplanet.com 

If you or someone you know wishes to receive the weekly summary as soon as it is completed, email kellyhammargren@gmail.com to be added to the early email list. 

If you wish to stop receiving the Weekly Summary of City Meetings please 

forward the weekly summary you received to kellyhammargren@gmail.com 

***************************** 

Free Virtual Screening of the Rights of Nature film  

Invisible Hand 

and Q&A with the directors 

sponsored by Sustainable Berkeley Coalition and Berkeley Citizens Action  

 

Register at 

https://www.invisiblehandfilm.com/berkeley-give-nature-a-chance/ 

via email to hammargrenkelly@gmail.com 

early registration is recommended 

the free virtual screening and Q&A is limited to 100 participants 

If you have any questions contact Kelly Hammargren at hammargrenkelly@gmail.com 

 

Q&A with the directors: 6 pm, Sunday, May 23. 

The 85 minute documentary film is available for viewing from  

4:00 pm PDT Saturday, May 22 to Sunday, May 23, 6 pm PDT 

Audiences have said INVISIBLE HAND is a “game changing” story about Rights of Nature and global battle between capitalism and democracy. Last Born in the Wilderness host Patrick Farnsworth has called the film “really, really beautiful” and “incredibly moving.” 

“We are honored to receive these awards for documenting the Rights of Nature story,” said Pribanic. “This is a turning point in the story of our culture, where the Indigenous legacy that once protected this land can resurface to take on capitalism and defend Nature’s rights.” 

What this documentary is offering is a way forward through Rights of Nature. You hear time and time again that a corporation has the rights of a person. The idea that Nature has no rights whatsoever is absurd,” ~ Mark Ruffalo 

The Rights of Nature in Berkeley  

The Resolution to Recognize the Rights of Nature is submitted by Councilmember Cheryl Davila for consideration by the Berkeley City Council at the October 27, 2020 City Council regular meeting.  

On October 13, 2020, the Berkeley City Council Agenda and Policy Committee removed Recognize the Rights of Nature from the proposed October 27, 2020 City Council agenda and referred the item to the Facilities, Infrastructure, Transportation, Environment and Sustainability Policy Committee (FITES).  

On March 3, 2021 FITES voted to forward the Rights of Nature to the full City Council with a qualified positive recommendation the final resolved clause of the draft resolution to place obligation on the City not the residents.  

On March 15 at the Agenda and Rules Policy Committee Mayor Arreguin said he was opposed to recognizing the rights of nature. 

The item was left on the council agenda for March 30.  

At the March 30 council meeting Mayor Arreguin said he supported the Rights of Nature and recommended moving the item to the consent calendar as a referral to the Peace and Justice Commission.  

At the same meeting after the consent vote approving the referral, the City Manager stated the Peace and Justice Commission would not be meeting because staff supporting the Peace and Justice Commission had been reassigned to support the EOC (Emergency Operation Center) for the COVID-19 emergency. 

Rights of Nature, legislative examples, history, timeline, documents and references,  

https://www.invisiblehandfilm.com/what-are-rights-of-nature/